{"entities":{"Q975778":{"pageid":977626,"ns":120,"title":"Item:Q975778","lastrevid":65717034,"modified":"2026-04-12T04:51:31Z","type":"item","id":"Q975778","labels":{"en":{"language":"en","value":"The irreducibility of personal obligation"}},"descriptions":{"en":{"language":"en","value":"scientific article; zbMATH DE number 5719894"}},"aliases":{},"claims":{"P31":[{"mainsnak":{"snaktype":"value","property":"P31","hash":"fd5912e4dab4b881a8eb0eb27e7893fef55176ad","datavalue":{"value":{"entity-type":"item","numeric-id":56887,"id":"Q56887"},"type":"wikibase-entityid"},"datatype":"wikibase-item"},"type":"statement","id":"Q975778$A6D54416-8767-473A-AD82-E7B6288966DD","rank":"normal"}],"P159":[{"mainsnak":{"snaktype":"value","property":"P159","hash":"5a17a2dc1064cde9993a416af5b46908e40b955e","datavalue":{"value":{"text":"The irreducibility of personal obligation","language":"en"},"type":"monolingualtext"},"datatype":"monolingualtext"},"type":"statement","id":"Q975778$174133AA-7834-408A-B77E-3CE02F9019C7","rank":"normal"}],"P225":[{"mainsnak":{"snaktype":"value","property":"P225","hash":"bfe308bd63411e98fb2e9110cc5c8f121996981c","datavalue":{"value":"1202.03014","type":"string"},"datatype":"external-id"},"type":"statement","id":"Q975778$39CA85BD-B705-482B-9365-41B19CD580EE","rank":"normal"}],"P16":[{"mainsnak":{"snaktype":"value","property":"P16","hash":"c8513dc6ad64a992bae72e016277602bc89bb4b5","datavalue":{"value":{"entity-type":"item","numeric-id":444554,"id":"Q444554"},"type":"wikibase-entityid"},"datatype":"wikibase-item"},"type":"statement","id":"Q975778$1273C49C-D089-441A-9609-7B3F87C7B4E2","rank":"normal"}],"P200":[{"mainsnak":{"snaktype":"value","property":"P200","hash":"e692f569038e7bcb7d3e72ba14d8d8e224046270","datavalue":{"value":{"entity-type":"item","numeric-id":169434,"id":"Q169434"},"type":"wikibase-entityid"},"datatype":"wikibase-item"},"type":"statement","id":"Q975778$F0AF6B72-B698-49EC-A2B3-AB3FBBD9A835","rank":"normal"}],"P28":[{"mainsnak":{"snaktype":"value","property":"P28","hash":"8330f0162b04ee97697b5c3b59dea76e14d14e04","datavalue":{"value":{"time":"+2010-06-11T00:00:00Z","timezone":0,"before":0,"after":0,"precision":11,"calendarmodel":"http://www.wikidata.org/entity/Q1985727"},"type":"time"},"datatype":"time"},"type":"statement","id":"Q975778$0CD99830-1C9A-48D9-BD94-FB5EC350ABFB","rank":"normal"}],"P1448":[{"mainsnak":{"snaktype":"value","property":"P1448","hash":"b4ee112a2075833eba0a9bdb78954bc5beaa6c95","datavalue":{"value":"The so-called Meinong-Chisholm Reduction (MCR) maintains that propositions of the ought-to-do, of personal obligation, are reducible to propositions of the ought-to-be, of impersonal obligations, that `\\(s\\) ought to \\(\\phi\\)' is logically equivalent to `it ought to be that \\(s\\,\\phi s\\)'. This paper argues against this reduction. The argument is based on a number of examples that are supposed to show that MCR has unacceptable consequences. The examples are of the general type found in the familiar Contrary-to-Duty (C-t-D) paradoxes stemming from Chisholm's own work; here they turn on the obligations of a plurality of agents. The supposedly unacceptable consequences depend on certain principles commonly assumed for deontic logic, e.g., with `\\(O\\)' for impersonal oughts, that \\(Op\\,\\&\\,Oq\\) entail \\(O(p\\,\\&\\, q)\\), and conversely, or that if \\(Op\\) and \\(p\\) necessitates \\(q\\) then \\(Oq\\), etc., and how these principles preclude conflicts of obligation. The author does not consider whether the initial plausibility of MCR might itself count as a reason to question those principles. The author likewise does not consider whether the representation of the examples might suffer from the expressive limitations of the background deontic language, as revealed by other forms of C-t-D paradox. The discussion throughout is informal. The paper offers no account of the logic, if any, of statements of personal obligation, nor how such statements might be modelled. This makes it difficult to assess the import of the examples and the principles on which the conclusions depend.   There are numerous lacunae in the References.","type":"string"},"datatype":"string"},"type":"statement","id":"Q975778$1DE6005B-A7FF-4607-A9A8-0916A01C7B3C","rank":"normal"}],"P1447":[{"mainsnak":{"snaktype":"value","property":"P1447","hash":"6f6a90c2765c02ad5e37dcfdbed0ddc3c8315703","datavalue":{"value":{"entity-type":"item","numeric-id":482532,"id":"Q482532"},"type":"wikibase-entityid"},"datatype":"wikibase-item"},"type":"statement","id":"Q975778$8F6FF8B1-65F2-41B0-B77E-F5659B43DB4F","rank":"normal"}],"P226":[{"mainsnak":{"snaktype":"value","property":"P226","hash":"48a2830216eefdc24b89ba9895c8f20366f6740d","datavalue":{"value":"03A05","type":"string"},"datatype":"external-id"},"type":"statement","id":"Q975778$266AA5D7-6A95-4411-98B5-C6313E047B9F","rank":"normal"}],"P1451":[{"mainsnak":{"snaktype":"value","property":"P1451","hash":"2588c142d5cee3783e80537e8e7db716101eb927","datavalue":{"value":"5719894","type":"string"},"datatype":"external-id"},"type":"statement","id":"Q975778$3B631D5C-5F3D-45CA-A82B-BEA1355E167D","rank":"normal"}],"P1450":[{"mainsnak":{"snaktype":"value","property":"P1450","hash":"876b2502966741aed1dd9c0cdf487939d8a47327","datavalue":{"value":"personal obligation","type":"string"},"datatype":"string"},"type":"statement","id":"Q975778$0F4299B4-390F-46DD-B9C3-9DFEFA7C7552","rank":"normal"},{"mainsnak":{"snaktype":"value","property":"P1450","hash":"0210f089df1bbaabb648c373da2a4d188266f9cd","datavalue":{"value":"impersonal obligation","type":"string"},"datatype":"string"},"type":"statement","id":"Q975778$C7381782-35BD-4210-A17D-6558ABB7BF76","rank":"normal"},{"mainsnak":{"snaktype":"value","property":"P1450","hash":"85e0be8d897d35f753fafdd73f20eb8efb03f09a","datavalue":{"value":"Meinong-Chisholm reduction","type":"string"},"datatype":"string"},"type":"statement","id":"Q975778$A040F176-0112-425B-BEA4-FAEC0D3A50A9","rank":"normal"},{"mainsnak":{"snaktype":"value","property":"P1450","hash":"2f721a2c9f1c73550aa1c5e3386d34c1b6269502","datavalue":{"value":"ought-to-do/ought-to-be","type":"string"},"datatype":"string"},"type":"statement","id":"Q975778$038130C1-5009-4D60-8ADD-6E895FB35BB9","rank":"normal"},{"mainsnak":{"snaktype":"value","property":"P1450","hash":"6e74baeea5a2042a2da11d84ce63303ae2365927","datavalue":{"value":"deontic paradoxes","type":"string"},"datatype":"string"},"type":"statement","id":"Q975778$063BA9BF-EC92-4228-BDC9-0CFD1913F82C","rank":"normal"}],"P1460":[{"mainsnak":{"snaktype":"value","property":"P1460","hash":"57f7fea50d2ce1b39b695c4a1313582eed405e38","datavalue":{"value":{"entity-type":"item","numeric-id":5976449,"id":"Q5976449"},"type":"wikibase-entityid"},"datatype":"wikibase-item"},"type":"statement","id":"Q975778$F0627BFB-B5D1-4C78-A4CD-361D1B5EAA25","rank":"normal"}],"P205":[{"mainsnak":{"snaktype":"value","property":"P205","hash":"5427140f200ff04df7771b37c3b2475b5f69c0c2","datavalue":{"value":"https://doi.org/10.1007/s10992-010-9125-7","type":"string"},"datatype":"url"},"type":"statement","id":"Q975778$BB9E23E7-55A3-4AE4-B97F-3A393450DCE2","rank":"normal"}],"P388":[{"mainsnak":{"snaktype":"value","property":"P388","hash":"4e4c5f8c493b73c66dde3533d24517cb0503b8a5","datavalue":{"value":"W1996860694","type":"string"},"datatype":"external-id"},"type":"statement","id":"Q975778$64B90A0B-C5A0-4528-8A54-0E3566C2FD7D","rank":"normal"}],"P223":[{"mainsnak":{"snaktype":"value","property":"P223","hash":"3ec35a71825a7df012d0ea488d0948495cfd075e","datavalue":{"value":{"entity-type":"item","numeric-id":5635426,"id":"Q5635426"},"type":"wikibase-entityid"},"datatype":"wikibase-item"},"type":"statement","id":"Q975778$78D8D164-FAAE-4DB9-9A30-E0DC02DA8B63","rank":"normal"},{"mainsnak":{"snaktype":"value","property":"P223","hash":"c186ee6674078e2a1f54d35503aeb7e301e6c9d9","datavalue":{"value":{"entity-type":"item","numeric-id":5275722,"id":"Q5275722"},"type":"wikibase-entityid"},"datatype":"wikibase-item"},"type":"statement","id":"Q975778$23861464-19BD-4CF9-B436-325B57823859","rank":"normal"},{"mainsnak":{"snaktype":"value","property":"P223","hash":"054e72bcd08285ab0508ccba7c969b455eea2707","datavalue":{"value":{"entity-type":"item","numeric-id":4532194,"id":"Q4532194"},"type":"wikibase-entityid"},"datatype":"wikibase-item"},"type":"statement","id":"Q975778$1972DB44-4B62-40D0-8FC8-3126239E1A61","rank":"normal"},{"mainsnak":{"snaktype":"value","property":"P223","hash":"223a9e00ee221c36aeb4d017d6b5523a198c4a73","datavalue":{"value":{"entity-type":"item","numeric-id":1292991,"id":"Q1292991"},"type":"wikibase-entityid"},"datatype":"wikibase-item"},"type":"statement","id":"Q975778$05F10C6F-8817-4503-93AB-44353B26BDB4","rank":"normal"},{"mainsnak":{"snaktype":"value","property":"P223","hash":"8394779242df5e11b4f2bb1a6e8c0760b8d9f561","datavalue":{"value":{"entity-type":"item","numeric-id":5422030,"id":"Q5422030"},"type":"wikibase-entityid"},"datatype":"wikibase-item"},"type":"statement","id":"Q975778$01E67B66-4C61-47C8-A4C2-61A24D95239B","rank":"normal"}],"P27":[{"mainsnak":{"snaktype":"value","property":"P27","hash":"b701c847385abe78682c756d1cc6b530c2744022","datavalue":{"value":"10.1007/S10992-010-9125-7","type":"string"},"datatype":"external-id"},"type":"statement","id":"Q975778$2B27F55F-FD15-4265-A95C-D11B04D206A4","rank":"normal"}],"P1643":[{"mainsnak":{"snaktype":"value","property":"P1643","hash":"bfe4575b43b02ac02f32874a266112a86ab571d7","datavalue":{"value":{"entity-type":"item","numeric-id":1922824,"id":"Q1922824"},"type":"wikibase-entityid"},"datatype":"wikibase-item"},"type":"statement","qualifiers":{"P1659":[{"snaktype":"value","property":"P1659","hash":"6de8ea61b8270b79f4654940e13ce2cbb47dceb5","datavalue":{"value":{"amount":"+0.80867577","unit":"1"},"type":"quantity"},"datatype":"quantity"}],"P1660":[{"snaktype":"value","property":"P1660","hash":"ac3c626774dcd0d16f89557f66586245841a01db","datavalue":{"value":{"entity-type":"item","numeric-id":6767936,"id":"Q6767936"},"type":"wikibase-entityid"},"datatype":"wikibase-item"}]},"qualifiers-order":["P1659","P1660"],"id":"Q975778$E9B037D8-8274-4898-8611-07702989BF12","rank":"normal"},{"mainsnak":{"snaktype":"value","property":"P1643","hash":"c46d011db68da89cb8b4f58f639e54de48f7cf2d","datavalue":{"value":{"entity-type":"item","numeric-id":5897321,"id":"Q5897321"},"type":"wikibase-entityid"},"datatype":"wikibase-item"},"type":"statement","qualifiers":{"P1659":[{"snaktype":"value","property":"P1659","hash":"87214fe18b25697d38d5f58fb154403d70d13bf4","datavalue":{"value":{"amount":"+0.8075246","unit":"1"},"type":"quantity"},"datatype":"quantity"}],"P1660":[{"snaktype":"value","property":"P1660","hash":"ac3c626774dcd0d16f89557f66586245841a01db","datavalue":{"value":{"entity-type":"item","numeric-id":6767936,"id":"Q6767936"},"type":"wikibase-entityid"},"datatype":"wikibase-item"}]},"qualifiers-order":["P1659","P1660"],"id":"Q975778$4F1F42D9-0D07-4491-86AE-B875C7BD760A","rank":"normal"},{"mainsnak":{"snaktype":"value","property":"P1643","hash":"09b52e4c26973db0c443530eb67c4918262dc502","datavalue":{"value":{"entity-type":"item","numeric-id":5901586,"id":"Q5901586"},"type":"wikibase-entityid"},"datatype":"wikibase-item"},"type":"statement","qualifiers":{"P1659":[{"snaktype":"value","property":"P1659","hash":"1eee277438dc7c14208dee394a914e729afbeb3a","datavalue":{"value":{"amount":"+0.80706567","unit":"1"},"type":"quantity"},"datatype":"quantity"}],"P1660":[{"snaktype":"value","property":"P1660","hash":"ac3c626774dcd0d16f89557f66586245841a01db","datavalue":{"value":{"entity-type":"item","numeric-id":6767936,"id":"Q6767936"},"type":"wikibase-entityid"},"datatype":"wikibase-item"}]},"qualifiers-order":["P1659","P1660"],"id":"Q975778$1377CA39-93A0-46A2-BB5E-A0BB26C8B476","rank":"normal"},{"mainsnak":{"snaktype":"value","property":"P1643","hash":"901c9d05344a779376d83e4584e6f5aef2a865b3","datavalue":{"value":{"entity-type":"item","numeric-id":2735775,"id":"Q2735775"},"type":"wikibase-entityid"},"datatype":"wikibase-item"},"type":"statement","qualifiers":{"P1659":[{"snaktype":"value","property":"P1659","hash":"2b5ba87f6622e37415ed0ff10926cd1cc314a0c8","datavalue":{"value":{"amount":"+0.8057694","unit":"1"},"type":"quantity"},"datatype":"quantity"}],"P1660":[{"snaktype":"value","property":"P1660","hash":"ac3c626774dcd0d16f89557f66586245841a01db","datavalue":{"value":{"entity-type":"item","numeric-id":6767936,"id":"Q6767936"},"type":"wikibase-entityid"},"datatype":"wikibase-item"}]},"qualifiers-order":["P1659","P1660"],"id":"Q975778$45D57126-B560-435F-BDD4-A61AA75737C4","rank":"normal"},{"mainsnak":{"snaktype":"value","property":"P1643","hash":"af9c50b62c1c5dccd1cbc5e096147004ce46bf1d","datavalue":{"value":{"entity-type":"item","numeric-id":3459090,"id":"Q3459090"},"type":"wikibase-entityid"},"datatype":"wikibase-item"},"type":"statement","qualifiers":{"P1659":[{"snaktype":"value","property":"P1659","hash":"4e19ec8a50ed48ff42600b59920c158e16c846b0","datavalue":{"value":{"amount":"+0.80438787","unit":"1"},"type":"quantity"},"datatype":"quantity"}],"P1660":[{"snaktype":"value","property":"P1660","hash":"ac3c626774dcd0d16f89557f66586245841a01db","datavalue":{"value":{"entity-type":"item","numeric-id":6767936,"id":"Q6767936"},"type":"wikibase-entityid"},"datatype":"wikibase-item"}]},"qualifiers-order":["P1659","P1660"],"id":"Q975778$AFFA2E8E-803E-4DF6-A204-4C917E90E48D","rank":"normal"},{"mainsnak":{"snaktype":"value","property":"P1643","hash":"4baf9a4cef4e2c33ae94212ebe1c46c647ec867c","datavalue":{"value":{"entity-type":"item","numeric-id":5878369,"id":"Q5878369"},"type":"wikibase-entityid"},"datatype":"wikibase-item"},"type":"statement","qualifiers":{"P1659":[{"snaktype":"value","property":"P1659","hash":"6d5515e6c377a16dd235670bad23a17d84a44851","datavalue":{"value":{"amount":"+0.8011254","unit":"1"},"type":"quantity"},"datatype":"quantity"}],"P1660":[{"snaktype":"value","property":"P1660","hash":"ac3c626774dcd0d16f89557f66586245841a01db","datavalue":{"value":{"entity-type":"item","numeric-id":6767936,"id":"Q6767936"},"type":"wikibase-entityid"},"datatype":"wikibase-item"}]},"qualifiers-order":["P1659","P1660"],"id":"Q975778$B8BB1852-AA84-40F3-BEF4-9C7EE9E221A6","rank":"normal"},{"mainsnak":{"snaktype":"value","property":"P1643","hash":"26b2d3275e3f873b8ea32cee6120587cbf063662","datavalue":{"value":{"entity-type":"item","numeric-id":4938869,"id":"Q4938869"},"type":"wikibase-entityid"},"datatype":"wikibase-item"},"type":"statement","qualifiers":{"P1659":[{"snaktype":"value","property":"P1659","hash":"4abbf805edbfa5a6f41620799e2ab3870804e731","datavalue":{"value":{"amount":"+0.794586","unit":"1"},"type":"quantity"},"datatype":"quantity"}],"P1660":[{"snaktype":"value","property":"P1660","hash":"ac3c626774dcd0d16f89557f66586245841a01db","datavalue":{"value":{"entity-type":"item","numeric-id":6767936,"id":"Q6767936"},"type":"wikibase-entityid"},"datatype":"wikibase-item"}]},"qualifiers-order":["P1659","P1660"],"id":"Q975778$90986A7E-57AB-4A80-B1E6-74FFB356428C","rank":"normal"},{"mainsnak":{"snaktype":"value","property":"P1643","hash":"d5d3e3e09ee169664fdb1bb5ea9144cf7dcdde7b","datavalue":{"value":{"entity-type":"item","numeric-id":3080094,"id":"Q3080094"},"type":"wikibase-entityid"},"datatype":"wikibase-item"},"type":"statement","qualifiers":{"P1659":[{"snaktype":"value","property":"P1659","hash":"46f5afc297ac4a3436585b7139913e0772f24f22","datavalue":{"value":{"amount":"+0.79151803","unit":"1"},"type":"quantity"},"datatype":"quantity"}],"P1660":[{"snaktype":"value","property":"P1660","hash":"ac3c626774dcd0d16f89557f66586245841a01db","datavalue":{"value":{"entity-type":"item","numeric-id":6767936,"id":"Q6767936"},"type":"wikibase-entityid"},"datatype":"wikibase-item"}]},"qualifiers-order":["P1659","P1660"],"id":"Q975778$327147A1-033F-4EC8-95E4-0E82C8E18366","rank":"normal"},{"mainsnak":{"snaktype":"value","property":"P1643","hash":"cfb7c6f5b1da22c0281666ff1ebb7bcf86f22fbb","datavalue":{"value":{"entity-type":"item","numeric-id":1353841,"id":"Q1353841"},"type":"wikibase-entityid"},"datatype":"wikibase-item"},"type":"statement","qualifiers":{"P1659":[{"snaktype":"value","property":"P1659","hash":"6d78960a2c7f2248e24eb6dfad26b100d9fb7fea","datavalue":{"value":{"amount":"+0.7877931","unit":"1"},"type":"quantity"},"datatype":"quantity"}],"P1660":[{"snaktype":"value","property":"P1660","hash":"ac3c626774dcd0d16f89557f66586245841a01db","datavalue":{"value":{"entity-type":"item","numeric-id":6767936,"id":"Q6767936"},"type":"wikibase-entityid"},"datatype":"wikibase-item"}]},"qualifiers-order":["P1659","P1660"],"id":"Q975778$A4BE095E-DFC7-4C90-9D20-8D4B560D9381","rank":"normal"},{"mainsnak":{"snaktype":"value","property":"P1643","hash":"a03aaa94313d8efa4eda98d82a473cc89c3c8bbf","datavalue":{"value":{"entity-type":"item","numeric-id":3655233,"id":"Q3655233"},"type":"wikibase-entityid"},"datatype":"wikibase-item"},"type":"statement","qualifiers":{"P1659":[{"snaktype":"value","property":"P1659","hash":"8cf9234365566c5e8a3a984208a6839447089e57","datavalue":{"value":{"amount":"+0.78712875","unit":"1"},"type":"quantity"},"datatype":"quantity"}],"P1660":[{"snaktype":"value","property":"P1660","hash":"ac3c626774dcd0d16f89557f66586245841a01db","datavalue":{"value":{"entity-type":"item","numeric-id":6767936,"id":"Q6767936"},"type":"wikibase-entityid"},"datatype":"wikibase-item"}]},"qualifiers-order":["P1659","P1660"],"id":"Q975778$09BF156A-6AC0-418B-B7BA-2C385C0C7BA8","rank":"normal"}]},"sitelinks":{"mardi":{"site":"mardi","title":"The irreducibility of personal obligation","badges":[],"url":"https://portal.mardi4nfdi.de/wiki/The_irreducibility_of_personal_obligation"}}}}}