FROM GRAVITONS TO GRAVITY: MYTHS AND REALITY

DOI10.1142/S0218271808012085zbMATH Open1153.83019arXivgr-qc/0409089MaRDI QIDQ3532155FDOQ3532155

Authors:

Publication date: 3 November 2008

Published in: International Journal of Modern Physics D (Search for Journal in Brave)

Abstract: There is a general belief, reinforced by statements in standard textbooks, that: (i) one can obtain the full non-linear Einstein's theory of gravity by coupling a massless, spin-2 field $h_{ab}$ self-consistently to the total energy momentum tensor, including its own; (ii) this procedure is unique and leads to Einstein-Hilbert action and (iii) it only uses standard concepts in Lorentz invariant field theory and does not involve any geometrical assumptions. After providing several reasons why such beliefs are suspect -- and critically re-examining several previous attempts -- we provide a detailed analysis aimed at clarifying the situation. First, we prove that it is extit{impossible} to obtain the Einstein-Hilbert (EH) action, starting from the standard action for gravitons in linear theory and iterating repeatedly. Second, we use the Taylor series expansion of the action for Einstein's theory, to identify the tensor $mathcal{S}^{ab}$, to which the graviton field $h_{ab}$ couples to the lowest order. We show that the second rank tensor $mathcal{S}^{ab}$ is {it not} the conventional energy momentum tensor $T^{ab}$ of the graviton and provide an explanation for this feature. Third, we construct the full nonlinear Einstein's theory with the source being spin-0 field, spin-1 field or relativistic particles by explicitly coupling the spin-2 field to this second rank tensor $mathcal{S}^{ab}$ order by order and summing up the infinite series. Finally, we construct the theory obtained by self consistently coupling $h_{ab}$ to the conventional energy momentum tensor $T^{ab}$ order by order and show that this does {it not} lead to Einstein's theory. (condensed).

Full work available at URL: https://arxiv.org/abs/gr-qc/0409089

zbMATH Keywords

gravityEinstein-Hilbert actiongraviton

Mathematics Subject Classification ID

Einstein's equations (general structure, canonical formalism, Cauchy problems) (83C05) Approximation procedures, weak fields in general relativity and gravitational theory (83C25) Relativistic gravitational theories other than Einstein's, including asymmetric field theories (83D05) Spinor and twistor methods in general relativity and gravitational theory; Newman-Penrose formalism (83C60) Geometrodynamics and the holographic principle (83E05)

Cites Work

• Cosmological constant -- the weight of the vacuum
• Title not available (Why is that?)
• On relativistic wave equations for particles of arbitrary spin in an electromagnetic field
• On Gauge Invariance and Vacuum Polarization
• Entropy of static spacetimes and microscopic density of states
• Covariant Conservation Laws in General Relativity
• GRAVITY: A NEW HOLOGRAPHIC PERSPECTIVE
• Classical and quantum thermodynamics of horizons in spherically symmetric spacetimes
• The cosmological constant problem
• Special-Relativistic Derivation of Generally Covariant Gravitation Theory
• THERMODYNAMICS OF HORIZONS: A COMPARISON OF SCHWARZSCHILD, RINDLER AND de SITTER SPACETIMES
• An alternative approach to the theory of gravitation
• Spin and Angular Momentum in General Relativity
• On the localization of the energy of a physical system in the general theory of relativity
• Variational aspects of relativistic field theories, with application to perfect fluids
• Conservation Laws in General Relativity
• Gravitation and Electromagnetism
• Possibility of Unequal Gravitational and Inertial Masses
• On the spin angular momentum of mesons
• The holography of gravity encoded in a relation between entropy, horizon area, and action for gravity
• IS GRAVITY AN INTRINSICALLY QUANTUM PHENOMENON? DYNAMICS OF GRAVITY FROM THE ENTROPY OF SPACE–TIME AND THE PRINCIPLE OF EQUIVALENCE
• GRAVITY AS ELASTICITY OF SPACETIME: A PARADIGM TO UNDERSTAND HORIZON THERMODYNAMICS AND COSMOLOGICAL CONSTANT
• ENTROPY OF HORIZONS, COMPLEX PATHS AND QUANTUM TUNNELLING
• Effective nonlocal Euclidean gravity
• Derivation of gauge invariance and the equivalence principle from Lorentz invariance of the S- matrix
• Gravity's immunity from vacuum: the holographic structure of semiclassical action
• Symmetry properties under arbitrary field redefinitions of the metric energy–momentum tensor in classical field theories and gravity
• Why gravity has no choice: Bulk spacetime dynamics is dictated by information entanglement across horizons
• Can the local energy-momentum conservation laws be derived solely from field equations?
• TOPOLOGICAL INTERPRETATION OF THE HORIZON TEMPERATURE

Cited In (33)

• Modified gravity: A unified approach to metric-affine models
• Noether and Hilbert (metric) energy-momentum tensors are not, in general, equivalent
• The asymptotic safety scenario in quantum gravity
• On massive spin 2 interactions
• Nobel Lecture: From weak interactions to gravitation
• Why not a sound postulate?
• Taming higher-derivative interactions and bootstrapping gravity with soft theorems
• Higher derivative theories for interacting massless gravitons in Minkowski spacetime
• Universally coupled massive gravity, III: dRGT-Maheshwari pure spin-2, Ogievetsky-Polubarinov and arbitrary mass terms
• Quantizing gravity using physical states of a superstring
• FROM WEAK INTERACTIONS TO GRAVITATION
• A connection between linearized Gauss–Bonnet gravity and classical electrodynamics II: Complete dual formulation
• Quantum general covariance
• Non-uniqueness of massless transverse-traceless graviton
• On scalar and vector fields coupled to the energy-momentum tensor
• Emergent gravity from off-shell energy fixing
• On the uniqueness of ghost-free special gravity
• An integrable geometrical foundation of gravity
• The dynamical approach to spin-2 gravity
• A connection between linearized Gauss–Bonnet gravity and classical electrodynamics
• Einsteins equations for spin 2 mass 0 from Noethers converse Hilbertian assertion
• Teleparallel Palatini theories
• Gravity from self-interaction redux
• Universally coupled massive gravity
• Unimodular gravity vs general relativity: a status report
• Energy–momentum tensor and duality symmetry of linearized gravity in the Fierz formalism
• Canonical Noether and the energy–momentum non-uniqueness problem in linearized gravity
• Dark energy and gravity
• It ain't necessarily so: gravitational waves and energy transport
• Have we lost spacetime on the way? Narrowing the gap between general relativity and quantum gravity
• What do gravitons say about (unimodular) gravity?
• Bootstrapping gravity and its extension to metric-affine theories
• The canonical structure of the first-order Einstein-Hilbert action

This page was built for publication: FROM GRAVITONS TO GRAVITY: MYTHS AND REALITY

Report a bug (only for logged in users!)Click here to report a bug for this page (MaRDI item Q3532155)