Counterexamples to the Gaussian vs. MZ derivatives Conjecture

arXiv2209.04095MaRDI QIDQ6410169FDOQ6410169

Authors: J. M. Ash, Stefan Catoiu, Hajrudin Fejzić 

Publication date: 8 September 2022

Abstract: J. Marcinkiewicz and A. Zygmund proved in 1936 that the special $n$-th generalized Riemann derivative $widetilde{D}_{n}f(x)$ with nodes $0,1,2,2^2,ldots,2^{n-1}$, is equivalent to the $n$-th Peano derivative $f_{(n)}(x)$, for all $n-1$ times Peano differentiable functions $f$ at~$x$. Call every $n$-th generalized Riemann derivative with this property an MZ derivative. A recent paper by the authors introduced the $n$-th Gaussian derivatives as the $n$-th generalized Riemann derivatives with nodes either $0,1,q,q^2,ldots,q^{n-1}$ or $1,q,q^2,ldots,q^n$, where $qeq0,pm1$, proved that the Gaussian derivatives are MZ derivatives, and conjectured that these are all MZ derivatives. In this article, we invalidate the conjecture in three different ways, by scales of generalized Riemann derivatives, by reference to the classification of generalized Riemann derivatives, and by means of an independent counterexample. In addition, we show that Riemann differentiation is not equivalent to a Gaussian differentiation in orders at least three, find an explicit description of the equivalence class of a generalized Riemann derivative, and prove a more general quantum analogue of the GGR Theorem. The symmetric versions of all these results are also included in the article.

Mathematics Subject Classification ID

(q)-calculus and related topics (05A30) Nondifferentiability (nondifferentiable functions, points of nondifferentiability), discontinuous derivatives (26A27) Linear difference operators (47B39) Differentiation (real functions of one variable): general theory, generalized derivatives, mean value theorems (26A24)

This page was built for publication: Counterexamples to the Gaussian vs. MZ derivatives Conjecture

Report a bug (only for logged in users!)Click here to report a bug for this page (MaRDI item Q6410169)