An inequality for group presentations

From MaRDI portal





Let \(G\) be a group which can be presented by \(b\) generators and \(r\) relations. Fix a prime \(p\), and define \(\Phi^1(G)=G'G^p\) (this is the Frattini subgroup of \(G\), if \(G\) is a finite \(p\)-group), and \(\Phi^2(G)=[\Phi^1(G),G]\Phi^1(G)^p\). Define integers \(d\) by \(|G/\Phi^1(G)|=p^d\) and \(e\) by \(|\Phi^1(G)/\Phi^2(G)|=p^e\). Further, define an integer \(f\) by \(|\Phi^1(G)/[\Phi^1(G),G]G^p|=p^f\) for \(p>2\). (A slight variation is necessary when \(p=2\).) \textit{W.~Gaschütz} and \textit{M.~F.~Newman} have proved [J. Reine Angew. Math. 245, 172-176 (1970; Zbl 0221.20023)] the following inequalities for the so-called deficiency \(r-b\) of a finite \(p\)-group \(G\) (one can take \(b=d\) in this case): \(r-b\geq d^2/2-d/2-e\) if \(p=2\), and \(r-b\geq d^2/2-3d/2-f\) if \(p>2\). The goal of the ingenious paper under review is to show that the two inequalities hold without any restriction on \(G\). The main idea is to pass to the pro-\(p\) completion of \(G\), and to use the theory of powerful \(p\)-groups; for the latter, see the book by \textit{J.~D.~Dixon, M.~P.~F.~du Sautoy, A.~Mann} and \textit{D.~Segal} [Analytic pro-\(p\) groups. Revised and enlarged by M. du Sautoy and D. Segal. 2nd ed. (Cambridge Studies in Advanced Mathematics 61, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge) (1999; Zbl 0934.20001)]. A typical application of such results is the following. If \(b\geq r+2\), then \(f>0\), that is, \(G\) has a non-Abelian quotient group that is a \(p\)-group. This is also a consequence of Lemma~5 on p.~73 of \textit{G. Baumslag}'s ``Topics in combinatorial group theory [Lectures in Mathematics, ETH Zürich. Birkhäuser, Zürich (1993; Zbl 0797.20001)].











This page was built for publication: An inequality for group presentations

Report a bug (only for logged in users!)Click here to report a bug for this page (MaRDI item Q4761497)