Exact solutions of compressible plane potential flows—a new method

From MaRDI portal





An attempt is made to methodologically produce (new) exact closed-form solutions of steady plane irrotational flow of barotropic inviscid compressible fluids. As for the author's motivation to this work, it may be quoted from their paper's introduction: ``The necessity for the present method arises from two serious shortcomings in two existing methods that deal with individual flow problems. First, only a small number of problems could be dealt with by the available methods. Second, mostly incomplete solution sets were obtained by the application of these two methods. By using a known variable substitution, the four governing equations in primitive variables in physical \((x,y)\)-plane are transformed into an undetermined system of five equations with \(\xi,\psi\) as new independent variables, where \(\xi\left( x,y\right)\) and \(\psi\left( x,y\right)\) are, respectively, the potential and the stream function of the flow. The new method should then consist in assuming the stream function in the compressible case to be a function of the stream function of a particular incompressible potential flow, i.e. the imaginary part of an analytic complex variable function, and then solving the transformed equation system by first letting \(\xi\) to be arbitrary. The solution so obtained should render the sought dynamic variables and the equation of state for which such a flow may be possible. This approach is applied to finding exact solutions for four compressible flows which are pendant to the following singularity-generated incompressible plane potential flows: vortex flow, radial flow, doublet flow and spiral flow. No boundary value problems have been considered. Reviewer's remarks: 1) The complete exact solutions to the vortex and source flow, rediscovered in this paper, are already known. Both are known to be possible for every mathematically reasonable choice of the barotropic law of gas. 2) The solution to the doublet flow, as presented in the paper, has nothing to do with a gas flow. The velocity becomes infinite along the circle \(r=\sqrt{ k_0/k_1}\cos \theta\), which is impossible for a gas flow. Also, this impossible solution is hardly a proof that a doublet-like flow for an adiabatic gas really does not exist. 3) The solution to the spiral flow, as presented in this paper, is a complete failure, because the gas density and the pressure given in the paper via equation (68) for \(\alpha\), are not single-valued functions. For the correct solution to the spiral flow for the case of an adiabatic gas see \textit{F. Ringleb} [Z. Angew. Math. Mech. 20, 185--198 (1940; Zbl 0023.41502)]. See also \textit{M. Sheffer}'s article ``Analytical theory of subsonic and supersonic flows, p. 10--11, in Encyclopedia of Physics (1960). 4) Contrary to the authors' opinion, there can be hardly a hope to produce further solutions of compressible flows by using this approach.











This page was built for publication: Exact solutions of compressible plane potential flows—a new method

Report a bug (only for logged in users!)Click here to report a bug for this page (MaRDI item Q4414907)