Hale on Caesar
This paper is about the problem if the principle: The number of \(Fs\) is the same as the number of \(Gs\) just in case the \(Fs\) can be one-one correlated with the \(Gs\), suffices as an explication of the concept of number. This problem was brought up by G.~Frege in his \textit{Grundlagen der Arithmetik}, and Frege explained why - in his opinion - the answer must be negative. Recently, Crispin Wright and Bob Hale expressed their disagreement with Frege. They invoke a so-called Sortal Inclusion Principle in order to defend their positive answer to the above question. The authors now explain why they find the position taken by Wright and Hale unsatisfying.
- Focus restored: Comments on John MacFarlane
- Isolation and non-arbitrary division: Frege's two criteria for counting
- Identity and sortals (and Caesar)
- Cardinality, counting, and equinumerosity
- Hale's argument from transitive counting
- Caesar Invictus†
- The (metaphysical) foundations of arithmetic?
- Pluralism and ``bad mathematical theories: challenging our prejudices
- What are numbers?
- A strengthening of the Caesar problem
- The Caesar-problem problem
This page was built for publication: Hale on Caesar
Report a bug (only for logged in users!)Click here to report a bug for this page (MaRDI item Q4354014)