Invariable generation of certain branch groups

From MaRDI portal





A group \(G\) is \textit{invariably generated (IG)} if \(G\) has a subset \(S\) such that for any choice of elements \(g_s \in G\), where \(s \in S\), the set \(\{g_s^{-1} s g_s \mid s \in S\}\) generates \(G\). If \(G\) has finite subset \(S\) with this property, then \(G\) is said to be \textit{finitely invariably generated (FIG)}. Invariable generation originally arose with the question of determining when the Galois group of a polynomial in \(\mathbb{Z}[X]\) is the full symmetric group [\textit{J. D. Dixon}, Discrete Math. 105, No. 1--3, 25--39 (1992; Zbl 0756.60010)]. The authors investigate invariable generation among key examples of branch groups. They first prove Proposition 2.1, which applies to all their examples but one: Let \(\mathcal{MN}\) be the class of groups for which every maximal subgroup is normal. Let \(G\) be a group where every proper subgroup lies in a maximal subgroup (e.g., \(G\) is finitely generated). Then \(G \in \mathcal{MN}\) if and only if every generating subset of \(G\) generates \(G\) invariably. (Proposition 2.1 generalizes Proposition 2.4 of [\textit{W. M. Kantor} et al., J. Algebra 348, No. 1, 302--314 (2011; Zbl 1248.20036)] which is stated for a finite nilpotent group \(G\).) In Theorem 1.1.(1), the authors observe that the torsion Grigorchuk groups, the torsion and the branch Grigorchuk-Gupta-Sidki groups (GGS groups), the torsion multi-EGS groups (EGS groups stand for extended Gupta-Sidki groups) and the non-torsion Šuniḱ groups that act on the binary rooted tree, are all known to be in \(\mathcal{MN}\). They infer from Proposition 2.1 that every such group is invariably generated by any of its generating sets. In particular, every such group is FIG. In addition, the authors use \textit{ad hoc} arguments to prove the following three results (Theorem 1.1, assertions (2) to (4)): If \(G\) is the first Grigorchuk group or a torsion GGS-group, then every finitely generated subgroup of \(G\) is FIG. If \(G\) is a torsion multi-EGS groups, then every finite-index subgroup of \(G\) is FIG. If \(G\) is a non-torsion Šuniḱ group that acts on the binary rooted tree, then \(G\) is FIG but \(G \notin \mathcal{MN}\). The paper also contains results on the generating graphs of the \(2\)-generated groups in \(\mathcal{MN}\) (Theorem 4.4 and Corollary 4.5). The paper is a pleasant read. It mentions several stimulating open questions, among which the question as to whether every branch group is IG.











This page was built for publication: Invariable generation of certain branch groups

Report a bug (only for logged in users!)Click here to report a bug for this page (MaRDI item Q6971078)