Geometric algebra with applications in science and engineering (Q2732065)
From MaRDI portal
!
This is the item page for this Wikibase entity, intended for internal use and editing purposes. Please use the normal view instead:
scientific article; zbMATH DE number 1627116
| Language | Label | Description | Also known as |
|---|---|---|---|
| default for all languages | No label defined |
||
| English | Geometric algebra with applications in science and engineering |
scientific article; zbMATH DE number 1627116 |
Statements
31 July 2001
0 references
Geometric algebra
0 references
Science
0 references
Engineering
0 references
Clifford algebra
0 references
Grassmann-Cayley algebra
0 references
linear algebra
0 references
matrix methods
0 references
robotics
0 references
perception
0 references
camera calibration
0 references
space control
0 references
navigation
0 references
quaternion optimization
0 references
kinematics
0 references
join
0 references
meet
0 references
joints in robotics
0 references
flag manifold
0 references
electrodynamics
0 references
0.8329305052757263
0 references
0.8232020735740662
0 references
0.8035547733306885
0 references
Geometric algebra with applications in science and engineering (English)
0 references
Writing a review of ``Geometric Algebra with Applications in Science and Engineering,'' eds. Eduardo Bayro Corrochano and Garret Sobczyk, Birkhäuser, Boston, 2001, turned out to be a difficult task since the quality of the contributed chapters varies widely. The book is organized in seven parts and contains 25 chapters. Some but not all of the chapters have been presented at the 5th International Conference on `Clifford Algebras and their Applications in Mathematical Physics' held at Ixtapa-Zihuatanejo, Mexico, June 27-July 4, 1999. Let us restate some of the goals that the Editors have set up for the book, and discuss how successful they have been in meeting these goals. The Editors state that their goal is ``to present a unified mathematical treatment of diverse problems in mathematics, physics, computer science, and engineering''. They want to address a ``broad audience'' and, at the same time, ``bring together under a single cover the most recent advances in the application of geometric [Clifford] algebra.'' Furthermore, since the Editors believe ``that the time is ripe for the general recognition of the powerful tools of geometric [Clifford] algebra by the much larger scientific communities,'' in the preface they invite, even twice, ``\dots{} communities of scientists and engineers who are seeking new mathematical tools to solve the even more complicated problems of the 21st century'' to read the book. Their conclusion is that ``\dots{} this book will prove invaluable to anyone interested in Euclidean and non-Euclidean geometries.'' Hence, the standards are set from the beginning. Let us visit a few places in the book to check whether these standards have been met, whether the book can address such a broad audience, and whether it can serve as a starting point for problem solving in the 21st century. Already in the first chapter the author ``assume[s] that this audience is familiar with the Geometric [Clifford] Algebra, so [that he] can proceed rapidly without belabouring the basics.'' However, a slower pace would have been more appropriate and preferred here since the reader encounters, in the same chapter, statements like ``In the Euclidean case, it takes three points to define a line,'' where the concepts of a line and a linear measure on it are hopelessly mixed. Then, the author claims that ``Grassmann \dots{} did not have null vectors.'' Jumping over other peculiarities like an equation number pointing to nowhere or some questionable historical remarks, the interested reader learns in chapter 2 that ``the \(2^n\)-dimensional Grassmann algebra \({\mathcal G}_N\) of the null cone \({\mathcal N}\)'' is defined to have, besides the identity, only nil-potent elements and it is generated from null vectors. What shall a newcomer to the field believe in now? Also, but not only there, the second chapter is full of grammatical and typographical errors. One even finds sense-changing typos in subsection headings. Even worse, the author spoils his own goal as Editor in stating that ``the major objectives of this [second] chapter is to develop the main ideas of geometric [Clifford] algebra in such a way that matrix methods can be employed \dots{}'' and speaks about ``natural matrix multiplication.'' Misspelling Ernst Witt's last name as ``Witte'' in the text and in the index shows either poor proofreading by the author or, even worse, lack of knowledge about Witt's important original works. Furthermore, the dyadic product is denoted by a dot, a symbol already reserved for the inner product, while other mathematical terms undergo notational changes in the middle of a discussion: This will only confuse the reader, and especially, a newcomer. A lack of knowledge of projective geometry is displayed in Theorem 3, where ``Desargues' Configuration'' is proved! However, the proof uses commutative coordinates which already imply Pappus and, therefore, Desargues [see \textit{L. Kadison} and \textit{M. T. Kromann}, ``Projective Geometry and Modern Algebra,'' Birkhäuser, Boston (1996; Zbl 0848.51001), or \textit{D. Hilbert}, ``Grundlagen der Geometrie'' (1899; JFM 30.0424.01), 14th ed., Teubner, Stuttgart (1999; Zbl 0933.01031)]. These peculiarities are amplified by using non-standard mathematical notation. For example, homogeneous coordinates are used throughout the book in an inconsistent way for both, the affine and the projective, geometries. Let us jump to chapter 7. There we learn that the Grassmann-Cayley algebra ``expresses the ideas of projective geometry, such as the meet and join, very elegantly, [but that] it lacks an inner (regressive) product \dots{} .'' However, the meet was already introduced by Grassmann as the regressive product in his `Lineare Ausdehnungslehre' from 1844 (the name regressive was coined by Grassmann but he used `eingewandtes Product' in early writings). A clear presentation of the regressive product can be found in \textit{H. Grassmann}, `Die Ausdehnungslehre', Enslin, Berlin (1862). After jumping to chapter 21 we are informed there about the ``applications of geometric [Clifford] algebras in physics and [their] links with engineering''. However, looking through the chapter and into its references, the title should be changed to ``our applications\dots''. This is because all recent works on Dirac operators, non-commutative instances of Clifford algebras, flag manifolds in string, brane and M-theory are silently omitted and not even mentioned. Geometric Algebra shows up as a closed circle with no hint for the newcomer how to link the material in this chapter to recent developments. In the reviewer's eyes the experiment to print a web site as a book chapter has failed. Comparing the chapter with its web site, the latter is much more informative, detailed, and may be also more recent. Why then print it? The collection of all references at the end of the book turned out to be cumbersome, since it turned out to be difficult to look up references which are not consecutively numbered but only for each chapter. Summarizing these randomly picked points, the book is neither carefully edited, having inner inconsistencies which are not addressed or commented by the Editors, nor can it serve as a starting point for newcomers who are indeed not assumed to be in the audience (e.g., chapter 1). A newcomer will be confounded by the sense-changing typos, not learned historical statements and even errors in the presentation which can be found in a considerable number of chapters. The reviewer fears that the Editors spent too much effort in presenting six of their own/joint papers and missed the opportunity to make the book into a coherent, well-written and useful guide where ``scientists and engineers [will be] seeking new mathematical tools''. He has found also no evidence of an ``excellent proofreading''. Is this a bad book? No! The reader, who has a pre-knowledge of the field to know which chapters to skip, will find a lot of good and even high quality papers. Theorem proving is an upcoming field in geometrical reasoning. The revised Clifford geometric formulation of problems in computer vision, camera localization and shape reconstruction bear interesting ideas. ``Robot kinematics and flags'' is a quite readable, unpretentious, and sound chapter which might attract newcomers and the learned! Another such highlight is the chapter on ``quaternion optimization problems'' which teaches to the reader more geometric [quaternion] algebra while examining various practical examples than many `basic introductions' do. Beside some good quality papers, section VII on computational tools might promote a use of such symbolic and numeric calculators. Moreover, we find in this part not only descriptions of software (as stated in the preface) but also sound mathematics. The ability to calculate seems to prevent authors from making wrong statements. It really opens new fields for research and new possibilities for teaching! Generally we find that the more practical the chapters are, the more sound is the presentation. However, due to the unevenness in presentation, proofreading, notation and a certain mismatch between the stated goals and the book itself, reading this book from cover-to-cover requires a tremendous effort and presents the reader with a challenge. Those who can select their reading material will certainly benefit from this volume. Those who are entering the field and are searching for a general mathematical source for problem solving in the 21st century, should continue their search!
0 references