No label defined (Q3158274)

From MaRDI portal

!

This is the item page for this Wikibase entity, intended for internal use and editing purposes. Please use the normal view instead:

scientific article; zbMATH DE number 2130676
Language Label Description Also known as
default for all languages
No label defined
    English
    No label defined
    scientific article; zbMATH DE number 2130676

      Statements

      24 January 2005
      0 references
      Lucasian professorship
      0 references
      astronomy
      0 references
      cosmology
      0 references
      theology
      0 references
      science
      0 references
      debates
      0 references
      politics
      0 references
      society
      0 references
      Cambridge
      0 references
      Eager to shed new light on the amazing developments that occurred in the physical sciences at Cambridge University over the last 350 years, thirteen scholars present an account of the university's most prestigious academic position, that of the Lucasian professorship of mathematics. In 10 chapters, the book deals with the 17 men that held this chair, from \textit{I. Barrow} (1663--1669) and \textit{I. Newton} (1669--1702) to \textit{S. W. Hawking} (1980--). The quality of their contribution or the duration of their tenure vary dramatically. However, by ensuring continuity, their chair `has attained a certain form of immortality' (p.426), nowhere more evident than in Hawking's case! An ardent admirer of Newton, \textit{C. Babbage} (1828--1839), \textit{G. G. Stokes} (1849--1903) and \textit{P. Dirac} (1932--1969), Hawking longed to make a contribution as significant to Newton's gravitational theory or Dirac's version of the Big Bang theory in the field of cosmology. Due to his frail health, he felt he did not deserve this position, certain that he would never be able to match Stokes' successful tenure of 54 years. He cherished Babbage's work on calculating machines, and for all its lack of immediate impact, he gratefully acknowledged him as the forerunner of computer science, which indeed proved an indispensable asset to his singular career. At first glance, and for indisputable reasons, these five figures stand at the core of this volume. However, the reader soon realizes that the authors of the articles go beyond appraisals of intelligence, originality and insight. Avoiding administrative or technical details, they hint, in a critical manner, at the basic achievements of each Lucasian professor, paying attention to the neglected social and political milieu within which their philosophical and theological views had been shaped largely influencing in turn their scientific research. How far had the chair itself a substantial impact on the activities of its holders? The following instances manifest the complexity of this issue. For Newton, his 30 years of activity as fellow of Trinity College largely overshadowed his professorial duties. For \textit{W. Whiston} (1702--1710), \textit{N. Saunderson} (1711--1739) and \textit{J. Colson} (1739--1760), the chair was conceived as the perfect post through which to popularize and establish Newtonian mathematics and mechanics, facing a hostile movement of anti-Newtonianism (chs.3--4). \textit{J. King} (1839--1849) used his position in order to influence the examination system (ch.7), while in the case of Stokes, the chair reinforced his research in physics, granting him tremendous authority on a wide range of subjects (ibid.). Dirac, on the other hand, displayed total indifference to his post and lived a monastic life, hardly attracting any research students. A Nobel winner, he brought together quantum mechanics and special relativity, being faithful only to the beauty of his formulae (ch.9). Religion influenced to no slight degree some professors' views on the philosophy of nature, which accounted for their scientific preferences and the methodological tools deployed in their research. At times, theological beliefs influenced the very duration of their tenure. Newton was forced to conceal his heterodoxy, but the evangelical Stokes, two centuries later, was free to express his beliefs openly. With a touch of bitter irony, we read that the anti-Trinitarian Whiston was dismissed `for having too much faith' while his successor, the blind Saunderson, was preferred `for having none' (p. 176). The latter's example influenced the Enlightenment philosopher Diderot, and, interestingly, Babbage's study of the mechanization of thought had a significant effect upon young \textit{C. Darwin} (p. 286). The evolution theory of Darwin and his disciples: became a source of intellectual debates in Victorian England. `If for Darwin the doctrine of eternal punishment was a good reason to abandon Christianity', for Stokes `it was a good reason to re-examine the Bible more carefully' (p. 316). For, as Stokes held, `True science and true religion' could not contradict each other (p. 321). On the whole, cosmological debates prevail in the best part of this volume. The myth of lack of eminent 18th century mathematicians arises in ch.5 which focuses on two capable analysts and educators, \textit{E. Waring} (1760--1798) and \textit{I. Milner} (1798--1820). Keen on experiments and demonstration devices, Waring had a brilliant talent at number theory, while both men tried hard to sustain strong connections between the natural and moral worlds of late-Georgian England. Covering the period from 1820 to 1839, the next chapter records the diverse activities of \textit{R. Woodhouse} (1820--1822), \textit{T. Turton} (1822--1826), \textit{G. B. Airy} (1826--1828) and Babbage, none of whom had the chance to consider this chair as an opportunity for advancement. Interestingly, the key figure in chapter 6 was not a Lucasian professor, but the head tutor at Trinity College. We speak of the controversial W. Whewell, an admirer of Milner's ideas. By trying (in vain) to introduce the Lagrangian calculus to the Cambridge curriculum in the 1800s, Woodhouse is considered a precursor of the Analytical Society, founded in 1811 by Babbage, J. F. Herschel and G. Peacock. The new attempt towards a reform which would focus on the abstraction and generality afforded by Continental mathematics, was somehow more successful, and Whewell was convinced at first that Newton's synthetic work would soon be read as a matter of curiosity, superseded, as it were, by Lagrangian and Laplacian mechanics. However, already in the 1820s, he became obsessed with the pedagogical and moral value of Newton's approach, stating firmly that the first sections of Newton's \textit{Principia}, together with Euclid's \textit{Elements} (the only form of pure mathematics he accepted) sufficed to form the core of what he defined as a `Liberal Education'. Through his papers, lectures and textbooks, Whewell managed to keep his own moral and intellectual commitments at the centre of the university's curriculum for many decades, aided by his disciple Airy, a promising astronomer and a better mathematician than Whewell Airy's semi-geometrical, semi-analytical \textit{Tracts} (1826) pleased Whewell, but were retrogressive compared to Woodhouse's advanced \textit{Physical} astronomy (1818). Whewell's moral philosophy, fully adopted by Stokes, prevails in chapter 7, but interestingly it subtly penetrates issues discussed in chapter 8 on \textit{J. Larmor} (1903--1932), although Whewell's name is not mentioned again. Along with Lorentz, Larmor was a notable precursor of Einstein, but preferred to devote his study to the anachronistic concept of aether, rejecting both quantum mechanics and relativity upon the grounds that they lacked intuitive mechanical foundation. This attitude is analogous to Whewell's antipathy for formal, abstract analysis and algebra. Moreover, like Whewell, Larmor felt it his duty to spread his deeply rooted views on the nature and purpose of science. In contrast to Whewell, Stokes and Larmor, \textit{J. Lighthill} (1969--1980) was indifferent to theology and moral philosophy. Interested, however, in nearly anything else (from Portuguese poetry to insects), he launched in the 1950s the fields of aeroacoustics and nonlinear acoustics, useful in aeronautics and disintegration of kidney stones, respectively (ch.10). Adorned with 52 illustrations, this fascinating book is distinguished for its gentle, humanistic tone and bitter humour, establishing new links between a wide variety of subjects. A masterpiece for any historian of science, it is highly recommended to holders of academic posts, whatever the status, as it accurately reflects those personal or scientific debates that pervade intellectual institutions to the present day.
      0 references

      Identifiers

      0 references
      0 references
      0 references
      0 references
      0 references
      0 references