No label defined (Q3261464)

From MaRDI portal

!

This is the item page for this Wikibase entity, intended for internal use and editing purposes. Please use the normal view instead:

scientific article; zbMATH DE number 3144558
Language Label Description Also known as
default for all languages
No label defined
    English
    No label defined
    scientific article; zbMATH DE number 3144558

      Statements

      1958
      0 references
      collected works
      0 references
      descriptive set theory
      0 references
      0 references
      This valuable volume contains, in Russian, practically all of Luzin's work on Descriptive Set Theory [D. S. Th.], consisting of a book (Leçons sur les ensembles analytiques et leurs applications, Paris 1930; cf. Russian adaptation, this Zbl 0051.291*) and 47 other notes, articles, memoirs, ... written in French (34) and Russian (13). In particular, this volume (for Vol. 1 cf. this Zbl. 51, 41) covers the main activity of Luzin in the time-interval 1917--1930 and especially contains, in Russian, Luzin's papers reviewed in Zbl 0003.10801; Zbl 0007.05704; Zbl 0008.24704; Zbl 0009.10502; Zbl 0009.30402; Zbl 0009.30403; Zbl 0009.32902; Zbl 0012.34401; Zbl 0012.34402; Zbl 0029.34703. (Cf. also L. V. Keldysh and P. S. Novikov: Luzin's papers on D. S. Th. where is given the analysis of Luzin's works and a list of his papers on the D. S. Th. ; see Zbl 0050.05502). This volume highly mirrors the personality of Luzin as mathematician as well as philosopher. Since some papers translated in this book were practically inaccessible to many mathematicians, the present volume is a welcome contribution for getting acquainted with the organizational work in Moscow at least in some sectors of mathematics. In this respect the work ,,O nekotorych rezul'tatach deskriptivnoĭ teorii funktsiĭ'' (On some results of D. S. Th.), Moskva 1955, 86 p. (pp. 552--616 in the present volume) is very significant. The main contributions of Luzin and other Russian mathematicians (Suslin, P. Aleksandrov, Kolmogorov, Novikov, Keldysh, Lyapunov, etc.) are contained or at least reflected in this volume. It is necessary to stress the particular importance of the following discoveries: Luzin's set (1914), A-operation jointly with A-sets (Suslin, 1917), CA-sets and projective sets (Luzin, 1917 on). Luzin keeps on pointing out the difficulties concerning CA-sets and other projective sets and insisting that these difficulties are basic and lie outside the scope of the Set Theory in the strict sense. He envisaged something that now, after Gödel's work and the contributions of Novikov and others, is a reality: the close tie between Set Theory and Mathematical Logic. It is all the more surprising that Luzin did not mention Gödel anywhere (as far as I can see) and did not compare Gödel's fundamental discovery in 1931 of the openness of every advanced mathematical discipline with his own prophecies written in 1927 (this volume 516 main passage)! is extremely interesting to observe to what extent Luzin was, in words, against purely logical and verbal manipulations in mathematics -- this in particular in connexion with Cantor's Continuum hypothesis \(H_0\), and on the other hand to point out that just Luzin in 1914 opened the vast field of consequences of \(H_0\), having found that \(H\), implies the existence of a linear ,,Luzin set'' and of ,,the proposition 01'' (cf. W. Sierpiński, L'hypothèse du continu, Warszawa 1932; this Zbl. 9, 302). Luzin was very surprised (p. 588) when Novikov (cf. Zbl 0012.34403) found ,,inverse'' separation principles for projective sets of the second class; he died in 1950 before Novikov's results for higher classes were published and the famous Luzin problem on the cardinality of CA-sets (,,Does every linear non-countable CA-set contain a perfect set?'') was settled [P. S. Novikov, Zbl 0053.36401; cf. also K. Gödel, Zbl 0020.29701; cf. this volume p. 240 where the hints (22) should be (32)]. The present volume contains: Preface (3--7) (written by redactors: spouses P. S. Novikov, L. V. Keldysh), cycle I (pp. 9--618), cycle II (619--680), cycle III (681--722), Annexes (723--744). The main part -- cycle I -- deals with those considerations on analytic and projective sets which are independent of \(H_0\) or the axiom of choice; it starts with the translation of the above-mentioned book by Luzin (pp. 11--269) and contains 21 notes, articles, memoirs (one of them jointly with Sierpiński, p. 273--284, and Novikov, 617--618, respectively); the time-span is 1917--1947. The cycle contains those results obtained without continuum hypothesis and axiom of choice. The cycle II (621--680) contains the papers on projective sets connected with \(H_0\); this part contains 5 articles (one jointly with Sierpiński, 621--623); let us mention that Luzin considered also the hypothesis \(2^{\aleph_0}=2^{\aleph_1}\). The cycle III (683--722) contains 9 papers (two jointly with Sierpiński, 686--688, 697--698) starting with the discovery of Luzin's set (1914) and terminating with the paper reviewed in Zbl 0029.34703; the results are tied up with \(H_0\) and the axiom of choice. The annexes contain: 1) commentary (pp. 725--739; in petit) consisting of 65 valuable hints, remarks, quotations, etc. (it would be very useful, if every hint contained the indications of the pages of the book to which the hint corresponds; the hint [4], p. 27, resp. 22, p. 240, should be [3], resp. [32]; with [35], p. 268, should be also the hint [39]); 2) list of 48 papers and works of Luzin (of them four jointly with Sierpiński and one jointly with Novikov); 3) contents (742--744).
      0 references

      Identifiers

      0 references
      0 references
      0 references
      0 references