No label defined (Q3718682)

From MaRDI portal

!

This is the item page for this Wikibase entity, intended for internal use and editing purposes. Please use the normal view instead:

scientific article; zbMATH DE number 3948228
Language Label Description Also known as
default for all languages
No label defined
    English
    No label defined
    scientific article; zbMATH DE number 3948228

      Statements

      0 references
      1985
      0 references
      dual consequence operations
      0 references
      Deontic propositional logics are usually axiomatized in Hilbert style, that is, as sets of formulae. In the paper under review, the author considers ways of axiomatizing some of the main deontic logics as consequence operations (in the well-known sense derived from Tarski) and, more unconventionally, as ''dual consequence operations'' (in the sense introduced by \textit{R. Wójcicki} [Bull. Sect. Logic, Pol. Acad. Sci. 2, 54-57 (1973)]. Reviewer's comments: There are some slips in the author's treatment of dual consequence operations. (1) The definitions do not agree. Wójcicki puts \(A\in dCn(X)\) iff there is a finite \(Y\subseteq X\) such that \(\cap \{Cn(B):\) \(B\in Y\}\subseteq Cn(A)\), whereas the author omits the condition of finitude of Y. (2) As a result, the author's definition could be simplified to putting \(A\in dCn(X)\) iff \(\cap \{Cn(B):\) \(B\in X\}\subseteq Cn(A)\). (3) Under either of these definitions, the author's assertion that \(X\subseteq (Cn Y)'\) implies dCn(X)\(\subseteq (Cn\) Y)', where prime indicates set-theoretic complement, fails. Counterexample: let p, q be distinct propositional variables and put \(X=\{p,q\}\) and \(Y=\{p\vee q\}\), taking Cn to be classical consequence. Then X is disjoint from Cn(Y) as required, but \(p\vee q\) is an element of both of dCn(X) and Cn(Y), contrary to assertion. (4) In general, for any consequence Cn including the classical propositional one, Wójcicki's concept of dual consequence reduces to: \(A\in dCn(X)\) iff there is a finite \(Y\subseteq X\) with \(\bigvee Y\in Cn(A)\), where \(\bigvee Y\) is the disjuntion of all the elements of Y. As the deontic logics considered by the author all include classical consequence, it appears pointless not to work with the reduced version.
      0 references

      Identifiers