No label defined (Q3818261)
From MaRDI portal
!
This is the item page for this Wikibase entity, intended for internal use and editing purposes. Please use the normal view instead:
scientific article; zbMATH DE number 4089488
| Language | Label | Description | Also known as |
|---|---|---|---|
| default for all languages | No label defined |
||
| English | No label defined |
scientific article; zbMATH DE number 4089488 |
Statements
1986
0 references
basic concepts of mathematics
0 references
structuring of mathematics
0 references
interdependence of mathematical structures
0 references
philosophy of Mathematics
0 references
nature of mathematical truth
0 references
nature and foundation of Mathematics
0 references
0.8451216220855713
0 references
0.7497034072875977
0 references
``This book is intended to describe the practical and conceptual origins of Mathematics and the character of its development - not in historical terms, but in intrinsic terms. Thus we ask: What is the function of Mathematics and what is its form ?'' This quote stands at the head of the book's introduction. The author is one of the most famous contemporanean mathematicians and has written highly estimated works such as `Homology', `A Survey of Modern Algebra' (together with G. Birkhoff) and `Categories for the Working Mathematician'. The book constitutes the product of many years of experience in lecturing and researching Mathematics, and the attempt of outlining a personal philosophy of Mathematics. A modest beginning of the authors working on the present task can be found in \textit{S. MacLane} [Cah. Topologie Geom. Differ. 21, 353-365 (1980; Zbl 0441.18001)] and, more sophisticated, in \textit{S. MacLane} [Am. Math. Mon. 88, 462-472 (1981; Zbl 0468.00019)]. While these articles are claiming a revival of studies on the philosophy of Mathematics, the scope of the present book wants to provide a background for a philosophy of Mathematics. Most concepts forwarded in the book are pure Mathematics announced by the chapter-headlines as follows: `Origins of Formal Structure', `From whole numbers to rational numbers', `Geometry', `Real Numbers', `Functions, Transformations, and Groups', `Concepts of Calculus', `Linear Algebra', `Forms of Space', `Mechanics', `Complex Analysis and Topology', `Sets, Logic, and Categories', `The Mathematical Network'. The book's structure aims at that latter `Mathematical network', i.e. the interconnections and interdependencies of many basic concepts of Mathematics as well a many advanced studies and deep-lying results. Parts of the network are presented graphically as early as the presentation of the structures makes it possible. The whole of the network can not be tied together for it is too complex; but the reader gets the general idea of it, i.e. he/she gets various insights into the building of all of Mathematics from different viewpoints. Proofs are mostly only sketched, and many results are simply given, but the idea of the matter's development always is present. The book delivers an organization of Mathematics out of intrinsic connections and not any new theory. Many references to applications and history and a special emphasis on interactions between science and Mathematics make for easy reading of the book. No matter whether one approaches the book as a professional mathematician, a student, an interested engineer or just an open-minded person: one surely will find something worth-while to read and to acquire. The reception of the book requires some exercise in reading Mathematics, but just by reading the book one can learn how to read Mathematics. One is not only confronted with formulas but also with many explanatory notes and graphs. Nevertheless, the legendary mathematical rigor is observed at all times. All in all, the book is like a piece of art. In the introduction the author poses six groups of questions on Mathematics touching philosophy of Mathematics: questions on origin, organization, on the formal and on the factual, on its depth and importance, its rigor and foundation, and the nature of mathematical truth. In this context he rejects standard views on the nature and foundation of Mathematics like logicism, platonism, set theory, formalism, intuitionism, and empiricism. Instead, he pragmatically examines what is actually present in the practice and in the formalism of Mathematics, and therefore wrote the mathematical parts of the book, thus also providing a missing link in Wittgenstein's investigations. From this inventory the author returns to the introductory questions, which in the last chapter get ``a different and more illuminating form''. A lot of ideas and reflections are involved, e.g. on extraction and formalization of ideas, on communicability and applicability, on possibilities of organization and foundation, on generalization and abstraction, on the fitting together of Mathematics and the fitting to the real world, and others. A standard of what sort of Mathematics is of worth is on the one hand established by the profound understanding of Mathematics and the insight into the ``nature'' of a mathematical problem, on the other hand by the fitting of (new) Mathematics into the mathematical network. Nodes and meshs of the network can change their importance and meaning within Mathematics' development. The author does not offer a fixed philosophy; that's beyond the scope of the book. For working out the author's subjective concept of Mathematics it is interesting to note what strikingly has been left out. For example, the famous four-colours-problem and its solution is not even mentioned; convexity and optimization are omitted as well as computer science, functional equations, integral transforms, integral equations, and nearly all operator theory. And probability and statistics are not ``now a part of Mathematics in our sense'', as the author claims. I wonder whether that new speciality of statistical geometry, which yet has yielded striking results in reconstruction of the beginning evolution of life, will fill a gap in the present mathematical network by adjoining probability and statistics. What's missing is any reference to ethics, an important part of philosophy. So the book perpetuates that blissful legend Mathematics being immune against value judgements. Going along with the author, there is a powerful interaction between science and Mathematics, and certainly different Mathematics, at least a different philosophy will emanate be it that you work on mathematical modelling of military topics or on the evolution of life. I myself personally would very much appreciate a progressive modelling of evolution, including social evolution, hoping a deeper understanding of the present evolution of life and mankind will give hints for a future evolution. There are enough urgent problems related to this subject, such as the purpose of (economic) evolution, stopping inflationing entropy, wealth finishes providing and saving human values. Maybe such mathematically external demands reveal intrinsic fittings. Conceptually, the book under discussion can be regarded as in opposition to the ``magnificent multivolume monster of Bourbaki'': Here in only one volume, the emphasis is not placed on a splendid formal organization of many advanced topics, but on the origins and applicabilities as well as the structural interdependencies of many basic concepts of Mathematics. A manifold grouping of structurizing viewpoints is set against an exquisite hierarchical order. Maybe the Godgiven is out while Euklid still is in. ``Mathematics (is) an array of forms, codifying ideas extracted from human activities and scientific problems and deployed in a network of formal rules, formal definitions, formal axiom systems, explicit theorems with their careful proof and the manifold interconnections of these forms. More briefly, Mathematics aims to understand, to manipulate, to develop, and to apply those aspects of the universe which are formal. This view, as expounded in this book, might be called formal functionalism.'' This is the book's closing statement. I have not discovered many misprints in the text, but an unfortunate accumulation of them in the bibliography of the present edition, where also a contradictory handling of italicizing can be found, just in contrary to the text. That's because automata have no competence on finishing but on contrasting a careful hand.
0 references