No label defined (Q4331481)

From MaRDI portal

!

This is the item page for this Wikibase entity, intended for internal use and editing purposes. Please use the normal view instead:

scientific article; zbMATH DE number 1742813
Language Label Description Also known as
default for all languages
No label defined
    English
    No label defined
    scientific article; zbMATH DE number 1742813

      Statements

      0 references
      21 May 2002
      0 references
      Ginzburg
      0 references
      Landau
      0 references
      Leontovich
      0 references
      Fok
      0 references
      Vlasov
      0 references
      Aleksandrov
      0 references
      Rukhadze
      0 references
      The Russian title refers to a person who is a ``gore-istorik,'' that is, ``a sad excuse for an historian,'' or ``a poor specimen of an historian.'' The article is a reply to \textit{A. F. Aleksandrov} and \textit{A. A. Rukhadze}, who in their 1997 article ``On the history of the fundamental works on the kinetic theory of plasma'' [Fizika Plazmy 23, p. 474 (Russian) (1997)], discussed the author's 1946 paper, written jointly with \textit{L. Landau, M. Leontovich}, and \textit{V. Fok}, ``On the inadequacy of A. A. Vlasov's work on generalized plasma theory and solid state physics'' [Zh. Èksp. Teor. Fiz. 16, 246 (Russian) (1946)]. The author, who had not worked in plasma physics after 1946, was unaware of the 1997 article until he received a viciously anti-semitic letter from a person using the name Kovrov, but giving no return address. In the letter the claim was made that Landau and others had poisoned Vlasov and the argument was supported with quotations from the article of Aleksandrov and Rukhadze. For that reason, the author decided to set the record straight. He gives the physics background in the form of the kinetic Boltzmann equation for a plasma, including the highly nontrivial collision term. In 1938, Vlasov proposed using the kinetic equation with a self-consistent field, allowing the application of the Maxwell equations. The author shows how Vlasov concluded that there exist undamped plasma waves in the equilibrium state of a Maxwell plasma. However, Landau had shown that the waves are damped because of the presence of a pole in one of the solutions of the dispersion equation. This damping has subsequently played an important role in plasma physics. Vlasov had simply neglected the possibility of collision-free wave damping, and the authors of the 1946 article pointed that out. In their 1997 article and in other publications, however, Aleksandrov and Rukhadze have reported on Ginzburg's motives, telling their readers that he ``hated Vlasov with every fiber of his being'' and found the term ``Vlasov's equation'' outrageous. As there seems to be no text that can be cited in support of this assertion, the grounds for it must be personal testimony; one wonders who the source was. In response the author cites the familiar phrase ``Keep on slinging mud; some of it will stick.'' The author quotes \textit{A. A. Rukhadze}'s book [\textit{Events and People} (in Russian), Tula (2000)], in which Rukhadze says, ``What didn't I like about Ginzburg? Mostly, it was his nationalistic orientation. He once said that `other things being equal, I naturally hire a Jew.' I think that is the reason he has always tried to emphasize that he was a student of Landau rather than Tamm.'' The author, a self-proclaimed internationalist, takes offense at those words. Obviously a careful reading of all the relevant works is called for. In any case, the publication of this reply is a fine example of the openness with which the Russians are now confronting the anti-Semites in their midst, a confrontation frequently featured in Russian news broadcasts. Editor's remark: See also the comment of \textit{V. D. Shafranov} in Plasma Physics Reports 27, No. 2, 180 (2001).
      0 references

      Identifiers