No label defined (Q4365301)

From MaRDI portal

!

This is the item page for this Wikibase entity, intended for internal use and editing purposes. Please use the normal view instead:

scientific article; zbMATH DE number 1082911
Language Label Description Also known as
default for all languages
No label defined
    English
    No label defined
    scientific article; zbMATH DE number 1082911

      Statements

      0 references
      4 November 1997
      0 references
      axiomatic method
      0 references
      formalism
      0 references
      universalism
      0 references
      closed systems
      0 references
      open systems
      0 references
      set theory
      0 references
      reverse mathematics
      0 references
      This paper contains a heavy criticism on mathematical logic which, according to the author, ``generates a flood of results but few ideas and the lack of ideas leads to a sheer byzantinism of most current production in mathematical logic'' (pp. 365-366). The author feels the need for rectifying logical misconceptions on the nature of mathematics which become especially significant if the philosophy of mathematics is, as is usually done, identified with the foundations of mathematics, which is the field of study of mathematical logic. The main target of his criticism is formalism. The criticism is based on a strong thesis concerning the basic assumptions of mathematical logic: The author claims (1) that the method of mathematics is the axiomatic method and (2) that the object of mathematical logic is the study of the axiomatic method (p. 370). The author distinguishes three forms of attitudes towards the axiomatic method: The ``grand theory'' version holds that ``a single theory is to be used to develop the whole of mathematics'' (p. 372), the ``big theory'' version, ``according to which a single theory will be used to develop not the whole of mathematics but only the whole of applicable mathematics'' (p. 374), and the ``little theory'' version, ``according to which a number of axiomatic theories will be used in the course of developing mathematics'' (p. 375). According to the author all these approaches tend towards regarding mathematics as a closed system whereas it should rather be seen as an open system. Only this second view takes the non-axiomatical, quasi-empirical character of mathematical practice into account. The author holds that this view is a consequence of Gödel's incompleteness theorem. Reviewer's comment: The author's criticism is based on a rather narrow reading of the axiomatic method. He accuses the representatives of the axiomatic method to confuse the presentation of mathematics with the process of mathematical discovery (p. 382). This is at least not true for one of the founders of the modern axiomatic method, David Hilbert, for whom it was above all a tool for testing the validity of theorems and objects which had been questioned. The fact that he distinguished proof theory and ``mathematics proper'' shows that the axiomatic method and an open view on mathematics do not necessarily exclude each other. For the entire collection see [Zbl 0894.03002].
      0 references

      Identifiers