No label defined (Q4368748)

From MaRDI portal

!

This is the item page for this Wikibase entity, intended for internal use and editing purposes. Please use the normal view instead:

scientific article; zbMATH DE number 1095289
Language Label Description Also known as
default for all languages
No label defined
    English
    No label defined
    scientific article; zbMATH DE number 1095289

      Statements

      8 December 1997
      0 references
      integral formulas
      0 references
      textbook
      0 references
      vector analysis
      0 references
      dyadic analysis
      0 references
      The second edition (first edition 1992; Zbl 0874.26003), rich of a new chapter on the history of vector analysis, is characterized by two main changes. First to avoid the usual pitfalls in the definition of the divergence and curl of a vector function, the author introduces in addition to the gradient operator \(\nabla\) a new symbolic vector that we note here \(\nabla^\circ\) (for typographical reasons, we do not use Tai's symbol, but the typing of the new notations for divergence and curl using La\TeX\ or Microsoft Word) is given (p. 183). And, the symbolic vector method developed by the author in the first edition is now formulated not only for curvilinear orthogonal systems of coordinates but also for general nonorthogonal systems. The book is divided into three main topics: Chapters 1-6 cover vector analysis, Chapter 7 is exclusively devoted to dyadic analysis and Chapter 8 is of historical nature. Six appendices containing many useful formulas complete the book. The first three chapters are comparable to those found in many books on vector analysis with in Chapter 1 a presentation of vector and dyadic algebra. It is not generally realized that the importance of a dyad is due to the fact that in an \(n\)-dimensional space any linear transformation \(A\) can be represented as the sum of at most \(n\) dyads \(Ax= \sum^n_{i=1}(a_i\cdot x)b^i\) (a similar decomposition is valid in an arbitrary Hilbert space for a special class of linear operators, for instance self-adjoint operators, then \(a_i\), \(b^i\) can be chosen to form a bi-orthogonal system). General curvilinear systems of coordinates are discussed in Chapter 2 with a particular attention to the Dupin coordinate system on a surface (in differential geometry people speak generally of Dupin cyclides). Chapter 3 presents a brief review of line, surface, and volume integrals with a special discussion of surface integrals. We jump to Chapter 6 that introduces quantities depending on space but also on time with an analysis of the important transport theorems due to Helmholtz, Maxwell and Reynolds. It is shown that the last two theorems can be derived from the Helmholtz one. Chapter 7 is devoted to dyadic analysis: divergence and curl of dyadic functions, vector-dyadic and dyadic-dyadic Green's theorems. Chapter 4 is the most important of the book. The elementary definition of the differential operators gradient, divergence, curl assumes an orthogonal Cartesian frame with the same length unit on each axis. To generalize these definitions to any system of coordinates Professor Tai uses a symbolic vector \(\nabla^\circ\) and symbolic expressions \(T(\nabla^\circ)\) which can be generated by substituting \(\nabla^\circ\) to any vector in a vector expression, for instance \(T(\nabla^\circ)= a\cdot\nabla^\circ\) so that \(\nabla^\circ\) can be treated as an ordinary vector. Of particular importance is the differential symbolic expression \(T(\nabla^\circ)= \lim_{\Delta V\to 0} \sum_i T(n_i)\Delta S_i/\Delta V\) in which \(\Delta S_i\) denotes the area of the surface enclosing the volume \(\Delta V\) and \(n_i\) the outward unit vector to \(\Delta S_i\), the running index \(i\) corresponds to the number of surfaces enclosing \(\Delta V\). In a system of coordinates where \(\Delta V= \Lambda \Delta \omega^1 \Delta\omega^2\Delta\omega^3\) and \(\Delta S_i= \Lambda r^i\Delta\omega^j \Delta\omega^k\) with \((i,j,k)= (1,2,3)\) in cyclic order, the differential symbolic expression becomes \(T(\nabla^\circ)= \Lambda^{-1} \sum^3_1\partial/\partial\omega^i T(\Lambda r^i)\). Making successively \(T(\nabla^\circ)=\nabla f\), \(\nabla\cdot{\mathbf F}\), \(\nabla\wedge{\mathbf F}\), where \(f\) and \({\mathbf F}\) are, respectively a scalar and vector function, yield the differential expressions in any curvilinear coordinate system for gradient, divergence, and curl, for instance in an orthogonal system \(\text{div }{\mathbf F}= \Omega^{-1} \sum^3_1\partial/\partial v^i\) \((\Omega h_i^{-1} F_i)\) and \(\Omega= h_1h_2h_3\), the \(h_i\)'s are the metric coefficients. Then, for instance, it is easy to get the symbolic expressions with double symbolic vectors providing the Laplacian of a vector function, the gradient of the divergence of a vector function and so on. The Gauss' and Green's theorems can be generalized to integrals involving symbolic expressions and many of the classical theorems in vector analysis can be readily derived from these generalized theorems by a proper choice of the symbolic expression. Chapter 5 is somewhat unusual since vector analysis on a surface is rarely discussed. Professor Tai defines surface symbolic vectors and symbolic expressions in the same way as in space but he shows how these surface entities can be obtained from the corresponding volume entities. Then, the differential expressions of the surface gradient, divergence, curl are derived in the general Dupin system. The Gauss' theorem for a surface is generalized to integrals involving symbolic expressions and a proper choice of these expressions yields classical results as the Stokes' theorem. Many formulas are given for surface symbolic expressions with a single symbolic vector and two functions or with two surface symbolic vectors and a single function. The aim of this chapter is ``to point out the inadequacy or illogic in the treatments of some basic topics in vector analysis during a period of approximately one hundred years''. The vector analysis starts some years ago after Maxwell's fundamental work with the waning of Hamilton's quaternion analysis in spite of ineffective disputes [recently, \textit{J. Lambek} in Math. Intell. 17, No. 4, 7-15 (1995; Zbl 0836.01001), discussed the interesting question ``If Hamilton had prevailed: quaternions in physics'']. Gibbs who may be considered as the founder of modern vector analysis introduced the symbol \(\nabla\) and gave correct expressions for the divergence and curl operators in Cartesian coordinates while Heaviside is the author of the misleading concept for the scalar and vector products between \(\nabla\) and a vector function. Unfortunately this misinterpretation has been the cause, as shown on many examples borrowed from various sources of many confusions and contradictions that appear still more clearly on nonorthogonal curvilinear coordinates. This justifies the use of a new symbol by Professor Tai. It is interesting to compare the method of symbolic vector to Brillouin's technique [\textit{L. Brillouin}: ``Les tenseurs en mécanique et élasticité'' (1946; Zbl 0063.00606)] for generalizing to any system of coordinates the elementary definition of differential operators. Following a Langevin's suggestion, he first defines these operators in an affine space where they keep their elementary form provided that gradient, divergence and curl work, respectively, upon a scalar, a contravariant density, and a covariant vector. Then, in a metric space, the metric tensor is used to get the ad hoc variance. For instance, starting from a contravariant vector \({\mathbf F}\), the contravariant density is \(|g|^{1/2}{\mathbf F}\), where \(|g|\) is the determinant of the metric tensor and \(\text{div }{\mathbf F}|g|^{-1/2}\partial_j(|g|^{1/2}{\mathbf F}^j)\) within orthogonal coordinates \(|g|^{1/2}= \Omega\), but one must be careful to note that \(F^i= h^{-1}_i F_i\) since vector and tensor notations do not correspond to the same definition of geometrical enfities.This comparison illustrates the simplicity of the vector symbolic method. Curiously enough Professor Tai was a former student of Professor Brillouin at Harvard in 1943-44. This carefully written book which is an important reference for dyadic analysis gives with detailed derivations a rigorous presentation of vector analysis. The symbolic method developed by the author and easy to master gives a clear picture of differential operators in an arbitrary metric space. This book can be warmly recommended to all researchers, instructors and students in engineering and physical sciences interested in a well-founded mathematical sound use of vector analysis.
      0 references

      Identifiers

      0 references
      0 references
      0 references
      0 references
      0 references
      0 references