No label defined (Q4429916)

From MaRDI portal

!

This is the item page for this Wikibase entity, intended for internal use and editing purposes. Please use the normal view instead:

scientific article; zbMATH DE number 1987695
Language Label Description Also known as
default for all languages
No label defined
    English
    No label defined
    scientific article; zbMATH DE number 1987695

      Statements

      0 references
      1 October 2003
      0 references
      asset pricing theory
      0 references
      mathematical finance
      0 references
      In this book, the author discusses whether advances in mathematical finance in the last four decades have significantly added to our understanding of financial markets. The author's view is that theories and models that are devised to describe elements of these financial markets are mathematically elegant but, in most instances, are not supported by sufficient evidence of their scientific validity. In the main, in his book, the author concentrates on financial scenarios related to asset pricing theory. At present, the asset pricing models in question are extensively used in the formulation of banking, investment, corporate finance and government policy. He suggests that the poor empirical record of the existing theories of asset pricing can be attributed to the efficient markets hypothesis (EMH) and not the models themselves. Furthermore, his contention is that the outcomes of tests of asset pricing theories that depend on historical market data or reanalysis of such data (and the associated assumptions made) are not reliable. With regard to the former problem, the author claims that assumptions of the type that supposes that markets are efficient information users and that risk is a quantity that can be determined explicitly can be relaxed to a large extent. If this process is carefully managed many of the original features of the asset pricing model can be retained. According to the author, the solution to the problems related to the reanalysis of historical data is to consider experimental markets instead of field markets. Experimental markets are no less real than the field markets and, in the opinion of the author, offer the only unambiguous answers to some of questions in asset pricing theory. The book is arranged in six chapters. The first being a review of the fundamentals of asset pricing theory. At the outset the author discusses dynamic programming and how it can be simplified when applied to portfolio analysis. Furthermore, he introduces the concept of an equilibrium. Eventually all of the aforegoing analysis in this chapter is reduced to the consideration of the Capital Asset Pricing Model (CAPM). The author emphasizes the properties that CAPM share with many other asset pricing models. In this regard, he specifically mentions that, in equilibrium, prices are fixed so that expected excess returns are proportional to the covariance with aggregate risk. Chapter 2 provides an investigation into the empirical methodology. Empirical tests of the asset pricing theory require the researcher to make additional assumptions that are not necessarily an integral part of the theory. The most noteworthy is the assumption that ties ex-ante beliefs (which determine prices) to the ex-post frequencies of the pay-offs, which has become known as the efficient markets hypothesis (EMH). In the book it is suggested that EMH dramatically simplifies the empirical methodology. The author reviews three important tests that are generated in this empirical framework, viz., tests of mean variance of efficiency of benchmark portfolios, the stochastic Euler equation test and the variance bounds tests. The third chapter offers an anthology of the literature on tests of asset pricing models. This is meant to allow the reader to develop a deeper understanding of the empirical evidence (or lack thereof) from financial markets that support existing asset pricing theories. The fourth chapter discusses whether the demands that are placed on empirical studies of historical data from field markets are too great. There is mixed evidence of the validity of the results from simple, purpose-built experimental markets. Some principles, like CAPM, are able to be verified, while others, like instantaneous equilibration, show a negative correlation with results from experimental markets. The laboratory environment allows us to unearth fundamental features of the economic theory that are difficult to detect in historical data. The author cites the example of such a phenomenon as the ranking of the Arrow-Debreu securities prices. Chapter 5 provides an investigation into how to proceed from EMH to efficient learning. Although there is a lack of understanding of how to extrapolate results found in the laboratory to the complicated field markets, the author investigates whether the econometric methodology has not been the cause of empirical failure of the theory of asset pricing. The first concept that the author suspects of this is EMH. He claims that EMH is unnecessarily strong with much of the simplicity of the EMH-based empirical methodology being able to be retained even if we omitted the most objectionable parts. The author develops a novel approach to the methodology for testing asset pricing models that enables the market to hold mistaken expectations at times, but still requires it to learn as is the case with EMH. The author names this new methodology the hypothesis of efficient learning markets (ELM). The final chapter revisits the scenario involving the use of historical data. The author studies the aftermarket performance of nearly five thousand U.S. initial public offerings (IPOs) in the period 1975 to 1995. This investigation provides partial support for the author's ELM theory. The examples suggests that, in some instances, EMH can be substituted by ELM in future studies involving the historical data from field markets.
      0 references

      Identifiers

      0 references
      0 references
      0 references
      0 references