No label defined (Q4518173)
From MaRDI portal
!
This is the item page for this Wikibase entity, intended for internal use and editing purposes. Please use the normal view instead:
scientific article; zbMATH DE number 1532744
| Language | Label | Description | Also known as |
|---|---|---|---|
| default for all languages | No label defined |
||
| English | No label defined |
scientific article; zbMATH DE number 1532744 |
Statements
20 November 2000
0 references
0.7439092993736267
0 references
In three separate, and yet continuous volumes (see Zbl 0984.01009 and Zbl 0984.01010 below), arranged in six chapters, this work attempts to survey geographical literature from antiquity till the European Renaissance and slightly thereafter. Of course, the main focus is the geographical literature that was produced during Islamic times, in conformity with the Frankfurt scholar Sezgin's stated aim of completing his magisterial opus magnum Geschichte des Arabischen Schrifttums (GAS). These three volumes now form volumes X, XI, XII of that series. The reader should be warned, however, that while the earlier volumes of GAS were published in the Netherlands by Brill, the three volumes under review are now published from Sezgin's own Frankfurt Institut für Geschichte der Arabisch-Islamischen Wissenschaften. Chapters I--III of the general survey are now covered in the first volume (GAS, X), while chapters IV--VI are covered in the second (GAS, XI), and volume three is devoted to pictures of various illustrative maps (GAS, XII). Of course, Sezgin's meticulous attachment to indices, that have always proved to be so helpful to researchers in the field in his other works, are here abundantly supplied as well. Volume GAS XI, pages 461--527 are devoted to the rich bibliography, while pages 531--576, 577--591, 592--598, 599--621, 622--716, are devoted to names of persons, book titles, tables of geographical coordinates, list of maps, and an index of names of localities and subjects, respectively. While the main focus of the work is a discussion of the veracity of a map ascribed to the time of the Abbasid caliph al-Ma'mūn (rl. 813--833), as preserved in a fourteenth century work and takes up the most interesting theoretical aspects of that attribution, in the final analysis that attribution is left unresolved with the information we now possess at hand. In itself, the map is not of great importance, and is incidentally published upside down by placing the north pole on top of the page to agree with the later European habit rather than keeping with the long-standing Arabic/Islamic tradition that goes all the way back to Aristotle himself where the South Pole was supposed to be placed on top. In this instance the markings on the map are written with the latter orientation in mind, and here reversed, by Sezgin himself I presume, for no explainable reason. The same policy is followed with other maps as well, an approach quite disorienting for all those who habitually approach Arabic/Islamic maps, that are, with some very few exceptions, oriented so that the South Pole is on top and all the markings oriented accordingly. This work also steers away from the mathematical treatment of geography, despite the fact that it purports to treat that subject in particular and takes Bīrūnī's work on Taḥdīd Nihāyāt al-Amākin (The Determination of the Coordinates of Positions, Beirut, 1967) as the foundational work for that discipline. For example, there is no exhaustive treatment of all the methods of geographical projections that were invented during Islamic times, starting with Ḥabash al-Ḥāsib (fl. 850), whose very interesting work on mathematical projection is altogether neglected here, and ending with the seventeenth century, where World-maps of the highest order of sophistication have recently come to the attention of the scholarly community in the richly illustrated publication by \textit{David King} [World-Maps, Brill (1999)] also of Frankfurt. Another aspect of Arabic/Islamic mathematical geography is also badly neglected here, namely, that which dealt with the orientation of geographical localities to the holy city of Mecca, knowing that Bırūnī's work just cited dealt specifically with this issue. No full treatment of such projections that could preserve orientation to Mecca from anywhere on the globe, and no full treatment of the importance of that concept to mathematical geography in Islamic civilization. As they stand, these three volumes constitute an extensive treasure house of all sorts of literary references to geographical representations, as well as geographical literature dealing with descriptions of localities and the like, fully documented in Sezgin's usual style, but the description of such representations that look like maps are, at best, only qualitatively detailed.
0 references