Earman and Norton on Supertasks that Generate Indeterminism (Q4527772)
From MaRDI portal
!
This is the item page for this Wikibase entity, intended for internal use and editing purposes. Please use the normal view instead:
scientific article; zbMATH DE number 1558027
| Language | Label | Description | Also known as |
|---|---|---|---|
| default for all languages | No label defined |
||
| English | Earman and Norton on Supertasks that Generate Indeterminism |
scientific article; zbMATH DE number 1558027 |
Statements
Earman and Norton on Supertasks that Generate Indeterminism (English)
0 references
4 July 2001
0 references
0 references
0.7556856
0 references
0 references
0 references
0 references
0 references
0.6788442
0 references
0.6736991
0 references
0 references
The definition of Pérez Laraudogoitia's supertask may be the following: ``A supertask is defined by infinitely many unit point masses \(P_1, P_2, P_3, \cdots\) arrayed at rest along the \(x\)-axis of space at positions \( x_1=\frac{1}{2}, x_2=\frac{3}{4}, x_3=\frac{7}{8}, \cdots\). At time \(t=0\) a unit point mass \(P_0\), moving at unit velocity, passes \(x=0\) and approaches the remaining masses. Infinitely many perfectly elastic collisions ensue with the unit velocity passing in succession from \(P_0\) to \(P_1\) to \(P_2\) etc. However, at \(t=1\), all collisions are completed and all masses are at rest.'' (Taken from a previous review of \textit{J. S. Alper}, \textit{M. Bridger}, \textit{J. Earman}, and \textit{J. D. Norton}, ``What is a Newtonian system? The failure of energy conservation and determinism in supertasks'', Synthese 124, 281--293 (2000; Zbl 1015.70005).) The present paper is an answer to the comments by \textit{J. Earman} and \textit{J. D. Norton} [Br. J. Philos. Sci. 49, 123--133 (1998; Zbl 0979.70005)] on the author's paper mentioned in the title [Br. J. Philos. Sci. 48, 49--54 (1997; Zbl 0979.70004)] where they stated that ``pathologies arise when we proceed to the limit of the composition of infinitely many of these collisions'' which is, due to the author, ``obvious. But a problem arises when they try to replace the general statement just quoted with a more explicit one about the underlying mechanisms responsible for indeterministic behaviour. According to the authors, such mechanisms are of two types, mentioned in the titles of their sections 2 (``Supertasks that depend on there being no upper limit to velocities``) and 3 (``Supertasks that depend on there being no lower bound to the size of the bodies'').'' Both arguments are correctly rejected by the author. What is not explained yet is the supertask itself which, using finite spheres instead of point masses, is characterized by the author's ``It is obvious that after time \(\Delta t = 1/2+1/4+1/8+1/16 + \cdots =1\) all of the spheres will lie at rest, but each of them will be slightly displaced to the right of its original position.'' Why should they?
0 references