No label defined (Q4769024)
From MaRDI portal
!
This is the item page for this Wikibase entity, intended for internal use and editing purposes. Please use the normal view instead:
scientific article; zbMATH DE number 3443594
| Language | Label | Description | Also known as |
|---|---|---|---|
| default for all languages | No label defined |
||
| English | No label defined |
scientific article; zbMATH DE number 3443594 |
Statements
1972
0 references
0.8067355751991272
0 references
0.7653210163116455
0 references
0.7471113801002502
0 references
This splendid book contains the reproductions, distributed over 25 plates, of the texts written on papyri preserved in Cairo, London and Copenhagen. R. Parker arranged the problems according to the time at which their statement and solution was written, the oldest (1--40) preserved from the third century B. C., the next section (41--52) corresponding to Ptolemaic times, then those of the Roman period (53--65), whereas problems 68--72 date from the second century A. D. We have to remark that problem 72 in fact indicates two different problems making the total of 73 problems. We do agree with the author that the problems 1, 19, 20, 21, 22, 41, 52, 68, 70, 71 must be considered as lost, the part of the text being damaged in such a degree that a reconstruction of statement and solution is impossible. Problems 54, 66, 67 give the mere construction of tables of multiples by iterated addition; 55 contains the multiplication 13 times 17 using the distributive law, normal for the Greek procedure rather not the Old Egyptian method of duplication and addition. Problems 2, 3, 57, 59 treat the multiplication of fractional numbers and 58, 60, 61 are concerned with the addition, subtraction and division. We have to remark here that the common denominator of the ''parts'' 3, 15, 21 is not chosen as the least common multiple but that the factors 5 and 7 lead to eliminating these factors by choosing a 35 times smaller counting unit. The procedures are all worked out exactly and it is only a lapsus that Parker suggests that an error occurred in the solution of problem 59 (comments page 68 to line 18). The problems 2 and 3 use the Greek notation (at that time well known) of fractions with demotic symbols. A first trial, however, to use a number of parts denoted by a numerator next to a denominator is known from the Old Babylonian Period (Susa Texts Aa, Bb); it is certainly not an Egyptian invention! The well known ''pole leaning on a wall'' is found in eight problems, 24--31, solved by simple applications of Pythagoras' theorem, which is also sufficient to compute the apothem in a pyramid, problem 39. The volume of a pyramid is computed in problem 40, whereas problems 42--45 are dealing with the volume of a truncated cone, computed as a cylinder of the same altitude and a diameter, which is the mean value of the diameters at the basis and at the top. The approximation for \(\pi\) is not the Old Egyptian one but simply \(\pi = 3\) in a relation \[ V = \{ [(d_1 + d_2)/2]^2 - (d_1 + d_2)/2]^2/4\} h. \] For the truncated pyramid we find in TMB 87 for the Old Babylonian Period \[ V = \{[(a + b)/2]^2 + [(a - b)/2J^2/3\} h \] which is an exact result. Next we mention the section on transformation of a ''piece of cloth of rectangular form'' by cutting off a strip of given width and applying the area to the remaining shortened side ... rather impossible in practice, but concerned with the first steps leading to an iterative procedure for the computation of square roots. We find these problems in 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 17. The rectangle with sides \(a\) and \(b\), area \(ab\) is transformed diminishing \(b\) by an arbitrarily chosen amount \(p\) and the ''new'' other side becomes \(a+ap(b-p)\). Problems 46--51 consider the relations: If to \(A\) is added the fraction \(p/q\) of \(A\) leading to the quantity \(B\), what fraction of \(B\) must be subtracted in order to come back to \(A\). This is done for \(1/5, 1/6, 1/7, 1/8, 1/9, 5/6\). Other problems on rectangles are 64 and 65, applying the agri mensor formula. In problems 7, 18 next to the area the ratio of the sides is given, whereas in 34, 35 the second datum is the length of the diagonal. Problems 62, 63 ask to determine \(\sqrt{10}\) and \(\sqrt{\tfrac12}\)which last value is computed taking one sixth of \(\sqrt{18}\), leading to a result corresponding to \(\sqrt{2}= 17/12\). The method used is that called after Heron but attested in the Old Babylonian Period. In problem 69 the diagonal of a square with side 10 is obtained as \(14\, 1/7\) corresponding to \(\sqrt{2}=99/70\). As the approximating fractions in the continued fraction for \(\sqrt{2}\) are \(3/2, 7/5, 1742, 41/29, 99/70\) one might ask whether the number \(29\) occurring in problem 70, having relations of squares and circles, should be related to \(41/29\). The problems 37, 36 and 38 treat the areas of the segments of a circle arising by inscribing a square in it or circumscribing a circle to an equilateral triangle. Naturally the problem of determining the diameter of a circle the area being given (32) and the transformation of a square area into a circular one (33) are also found in this collection of problems. There are some problems for which we have to indicate that we do not agree with Parker on the interpretation of statement or solution. Problem 23 is a normal hau-problem. The unhappy choosing of the translation ''question'' for sn, not satisfying Parker as he explicitly states, interchanges ''question'', i.e. what is asked, with ''unknown'', i. e. what is asked for ... and carrying out this interchange a normal text arises. The problem stated is \[ x + x/2 + x/4 + x/8 = \tfrac12 \] and adding the fractional coefficient in 1 5/6 1/30 1/120 the next step should be the division of \(\tfrac12\) by that complicated fraction ... therefore the scribe ... stops and indicates 15, being the number of the new variable \(x/8\). Dividing \(\tfrac12\) by 15 and multiplying by 8 the solution was found. Parker states that it is unclear why a half of \(1/15\) should be taken. The sudden stop by the scribe must have puzzled him. In the same way the reluctant choosing of the translation of sp by ''remainder'' instead of ''difference'', the meaning of problems 4, 5, 6, has escaped to Parker, who thought that given a series of terms the next term should be computed, whereas the scribe asked for the difference of the last two. In modern symbols: For \(1/p - 1/q\), determine \(p - q\) and divide 1 by \(q-p\). Multiplication into \(pq\) gives the resulting ''part''. One can leave apart a common factor of \(q\) and \(p\), as is shown in problem 4. In discussing problem 13 on ''clothes and prices'' Parker did not succeed in establishing the problem and its solution. The unhappy decision to interpret a number 5 (page 25, transcription line 4) indicating the number of 5 deben for which the clothes were bought, as the number of pieces of cloth, blocks Parker the way to the simple and well known type of problems. A merchant has bought three pieces of cloth, one of 48 cloth-(area)-units, a second measuring \(3\tfrac12\) by \(3\tfrac12\) of which one cloth cubit, one by one, is missing, thus leading to \(11\, 1/4\) cloth units and a square piece of \(2\tfrac12\) by \(2\tfrac12\) or \(6\,1/4\) cloth units. Together the three pieces measure \(65\tfrac12\) cloth units, which he bought for 5 deben silver. He wants to sell at a price giving him 6 deben. In order to count with integers he changes the unit of counting to \(\tfrac12\)-cloth units of which there are then 131. In order to have for all pieces integers he should, however, have chosen a quarter as new unit. The price at which should be sold is now given beforehand and first the check is made and indeed 5 deben, \(\tfrac12\) deben and 5 kite of silver arise, totalling to 6 deben. Then the deriving of the selling price starts. The 5 deben are 655/131 deben, the six deben lead to a price of 600/1310 kites and as \(600 = 524+76\) the selling price is \(1/3+1/15+ (7\tfrac12\,1/10)/131\) kites. Of this computation only the first reduction of the 5 deben and the last fractions are preserved. The problems 53 and 72(73) belong to the same class. We have to observe that in antiquity the summation of a series was carried out by a ''descente''. Rewriting 1 as \(n- (n - 1)\) or \((n - 1) - (n - 2) \ldots\) and summing we have the modern formula \(\sum_1^n = n\). Again as \(n(n+1) -(n - 1) n = 2n\) the same kind of cancellation leads to \[ 2\sum_1^n n = n(n+1) = H_n, \] the heteromêkos, the double of the triangular number \(T_n\). Summing the series of \(T_n\) one has to observe that \[ n(n+1)(n+2)- (n-1)n(n+1)=3n(n+1) \] in order to have \[ 3\sum_1^n n(n+ 1) = n(n+ 1) (n+2). \] Thus summing two times the series of natural numbers gives first the triangular numbers and then, summing the results again, the result given in the solution of problem 53. The heteromêkos leads to taking one \(n\)-th and one \((n + 1)\)-th part as the sum the number \(2n + 1\). Treating successive numbers one obtains, summing these, a sum of uneven numbers. If on takes \(n_i = n_{i-1} + 2\) four successive terms lead to a sum \(4(2n+7)\) and five to \(5(2n+9)\). Just as in Plato's Laws, VII, 819, the different terms are indicated by different metals. In problem 72 they are Ag, Au, Cu, Pb and the first term corresponds to \(n=6\) leading to 4 times 19 = 76 as a common denominator by which all terms must be divided in order to lead to one unit. Problem 73 is just indicated as having 5 terms. The initial value of \(n=21\) leads to 5 times 51 = 255 as the common denominator. Finally we remark that the first line of problem 56 should not be rendered by ''Cause that 2 make part of 35'' but by ''Form 2 35-parts''. The Egyptian method (following Plato's indication in Laws, VII, 819) is \textit{never} computing with fractions but only taking greater numbers of smaller units. In order to avoid confusion with modern fractions we write for \(1/ab\) simply \([ab]'\). Then taking an \((a+ b)\) times smaller unit we have that number of \([ab(a+b)]'\) of which we can, redistributing into two lots of \(a\) and \(b\) elements, reduce each term to a ''part'', i. e. \[ [ab]' =[a(a+b)]' + [b(a+b)' \] and therefore taking \([ab]' + [ab]'\) one has to halve each of the two ''parts'' leading to \[ [a(a+b)/2]' + [b(a+b)/2]'. \] Undoubtedly the Old Egyptian reduction by binomial decompositions of the ''double of a part'' is related in this highly important section, which though written about a thousand years later than the so called \(2/n\)-table of the Rhind papyrus shows the traditional method. The influence of Greek mathematics is evident throughout the collection of problems, many deviations of the Old-Egyptian-working are manifest, other procedures were unaltered and the importance of Parker's work lies exactly in this fact that it gives us an insight into the way of gradually changing the methods.
0 references