No label defined (Q4784060)

From MaRDI portal

!

This is the item page for this Wikibase entity, intended for internal use and editing purposes. Please use the normal view instead:

scientific article; zbMATH DE number 1843173
Language Label Description Also known as
default for all languages
No label defined
    English
    No label defined
    scientific article; zbMATH DE number 1843173

      Statements

      0 references
      8 December 2003
      0 references
      dialectical nature of mathematical research
      0 references
      methodology
      0 references
      mathematical discovery
      0 references
      This paper is aimed at producing a critical appraisal of \textit{I. Lakatos}' emphasis on the dialectical nature of mathematical research and discoveries. The optimistic author first argues that what he summarizes as the basic patterns of the methodology of the celebrated book ``Proofs and refutations'' [Cambridge: Cambridge Univ. Press (1976; Zbl 0334.00022)], namely ``monster-barring'', ``exception-barring'' and ``lemma-incorporation'', can be supplemented by further ones. Very cleverly, he suggests for instance ``lemma-exclusion'', clearly a ``non-Lakatosian'' and non-dialectical step in mathematical discovery. Freely and frequently, he insists on the ``limitations'' and on the ``weaknesses'' of the whole approach of Imre Lakatos. Continuing in this way, the author seems to firmly believe that what he calls the concept of a ``form of language'' can be used to achieve a better understanding of the historical development of geometry (sic). Apparently, this Wittgensteinian concept is borrowed from some deep part of the Tractatus Logico-Philosophicus, which, as everybody knows, is a treatise involving historico-philosophical studies about, say, for instance, early Fourier series or early algebraic topology, a treatise directly rooted in the mathematical experience of pre-formal mathematical concepts, a treatise much closer to the nineteenth century's mathematics than Lakatos' works! Under some strong non-continental epistemological influence, the author is conducted to assert that ``forms of language'' have evolved in logically stable universes, contrary to the verychaotic nature of scientific discoveries, contrary to the fact that most ``forms of language'' are difficult to learn and to study. Smooth evolution, with no dialectical seeking of coherence among a variety of examples. In short: methodology, without dialectic; simple answers, without long and hard research. Needless to say, the paper analyzes only very classical and very well-known examples, from a relatively superficial point of view. From the reviewer's point of view, epistemology of mathematics suffers considerably from the fact that some specialists in the field have a relatively limited mathematical culture and have never experienced what deep mathematical research is, as it virtually incorporates many of the dialectical aspects so clearly emphasized for the first time by Imre Lakatos and by Gaston Bachelard. It is not because the hesitations and the virtual dialectic do not appear in a published serious mathematical text that they do not exist. No magic formula (``game of language'') exists to describe mathematical discoveries, but problematic and dialectical propositions are closer to the truth than dogmatic ones. For the entire collection see [Zbl 0990.00016].
      0 references

      Identifiers