No label defined (Q5316372)

From MaRDI portal

!

This is the item page for this Wikibase entity, intended for internal use and editing purposes. Please use the normal view instead:

scientific article; zbMATH DE number 2204753
Language Label Description Also known as
default for all languages
No label defined
    English
    No label defined
    scientific article; zbMATH DE number 2204753

      Statements

      0 references
      12 September 2005
      0 references
      Continuum Hypothesis
      0 references
      \(H(\omega_2)\)
      0 references
      \(\Omega\)-logic
      0 references
      Axiom (\(\ast\))
      0 references
      In this expository paper the author describes his proposed ``solution'' to the Continuum Hypothesis. The starting point is the remark that CH ``concerns the structure \(H(\omega_2),\) so any reasonably complete understan\-ding of \(H(\omega_2)\) should resolve whether or not the \textsl{Continuum Hypothesis} is true''. The approach is incremental : ``First understand \(H(\omega),\) then understand \(H(\omega_1),\) and then understand \(H(\omega_2)\)''. \(H(\omega)\) is in essence simply the structure \(\langle\mathbb N,+,\times\rangle,\) the structure of arithmetic. It is important to note that the theory of this structure is invariant under forcing. The author argues that the axiom system ``Peano Axioms + Projective Determinacy'' is to \(H(\omega_1)\) what the system ``Peano Axioms'' is to \(H(\omega).\) Thus the problem is to find an analog of Projective Determinacy for \(H(\omega_2).\) The framework is that of \(\Omega\)-logic, a logic that extends usual first-order logic and (assuming the existence of a proper class of Woodin cardinals) satisfies a ``generic soundness'' requirement : if \(V_\alpha^\P\models\) ZFC and ZFC \(\vdash_\Omega\varphi,\) then \(V_\alpha^\P\models\varphi \;(\Omega\)-logic can be presented by a semantic notion of validity \((\models_\Omega)\) in a certain class of test structures, and by a syntactic notion of provability \((\vdash_\Omega),\) with proofs being witnessed by universally Baire sets). The author has isolated an axiom \((\ast)\) such that (assuming the existence of a proper class of Woodin cardinals and that of an inaccessible limit of Woodin cardinals) (a) for any sentence \(\varphi,\) either ZFC\(+(\ast)\vdash_\Omega\) ``\(H(\omega_2)\models\varphi"\) or ZFC\(+(\ast)\vdash_\Omega\) ``\(H(\omega_2)\models\neg\varphi",\) (b) ZFC\(+(\ast)\) is \(\Omega\)-consistent, and (c) \((\ast)\) implies \(2^{\aleph_0}=\aleph_2.\) (In fact, assuming the existence of a proper class of Woodin cardinals, if \((\alpha)\) for any \(\varphi,\) either ZFC\(+\Psi\vdash_\Omega\) ``\(H(\omega_2)\models\varphi"\) or ZFC\(+\Psi\vdash_\Omega\) ``\(H(\omega_2)\models\neg\varphi",\) and \((\beta) V_\kappa\models\text{ZFC}+\Psi,\) then CH is false). One thus ``recovers for the theory of the structure \(\langle H(\omega_2),\in\rangle\) the \textsl{empirical} completeness enjoyed by the theory of the structure \(\langle H(\omega),\in\rangle\)''. There remains to prove the so-called \(\Omega\) conjecture, which asserts that (assuming the existence of a proper class of Woodin cardinals) the completeness theorem holds for \(\Omega\)-logic. This conjecture is extensively discussed in the paper. For the entire collection see [Zbl 1064.03003].
      0 references

      Identifiers

      0 references
      0 references
      0 references
      0 references