The Scientific Work of Allesandro Piccolomini (Q5581580)
From MaRDI portal
!
This is the item page for this Wikibase entity, intended for internal use and editing purposes. Please use the normal view instead:
scientific article; zbMATH DE number 3299665
| Language | Label | Description | Also known as |
|---|---|---|---|
| default for all languages | No label defined |
||
| English | The Scientific Work of Allesandro Piccolomini |
scientific article; zbMATH DE number 3299665 |
Statements
The Scientific Work of Allesandro Piccolomini (English)
0 references
1969
0 references
history
0 references
0.7157001495361328
0 references
0.6948832273483276
0 references
Allesandro Piccolomini (1508--1579), titular archbishop of Patras and coadjutor to the archbishop of Siena, deserves notice because of the scarcity of Sienese writers on science, because, as a popularizer rather than original investigator, he wrote in Italian, and because, although he adhered to the cosmography and astronomy of Ptolemy and Aristotle, his arguments in favor of their doctrines reflect the introduction into European thought of arguments against them. While apologizing for writing on science in the vernacular, he insisted on his originality in doing so. In Piccolomini's ``Planetary Theory'' (1558) a lengthy discussion, provided here in English, is concerned with ``whether the representations invented by the astrologers [astronomers] to save the appearances of the planets are based on anything real in nature.'' Piccolomini considered the Ptolemaic theory useful but not representative of anything real. Suter called attention to Osiander's similar thoughts about the Copernican theory. He quoted another passage from the ``Planetary Theory'' in which Piccolomini, speaking of Venus and Mercury, emphasized the nobility and dignity of the sun and a passage from a posthumous edition of ``The Sphere of the Universe'' which cited the ``Planetary Theory'' and talked of the central position of the sun, between the orbits of Mercury and Venus on the one hand and those of the outer planets on the other. But Piccolomini did not make the sun the center of motion of even Venus and Mercury. ``The Sphere of the Universe'' written in 1540 in accord with the Ptolemaic and Aristotelian view, although slightly changed in later editions, was never altered in this respect. In the late edition Piccolomini argued against a diurnal motion of the earth, but, although he may well have heard of Copernicus, he never mentioned him. The keenness of Piccolomini's mind is shown by his discussion of infinity in the ``Natural Philosophy'' but his conservatism is also evident in his insistence on the pagan notion of an eternal universe. Because he was willing to oppose Aristotle when sense showed him the contrary, as Plato, too, had at times opposed his teacher, Piccolomini was able to write ``On the Greatness of the Quantity of Earth and Water'', holding correctly that the total quantity of earth is greater than the total quantity of water. However, on information gleaned from travellers, he erred in believing that the total amount of land on the earth's surface was slightly greater than the quantity of water. Piccolomini also wrote an exposition of Aristotle's formal logic and booklet on the fixed stars which contains star charts and tables. In his student days at Padua he had published in one volume an interpretation in Latin of Alexander of Aphrodisias' commentary on the ``Meteorologica'' and his own tract on the rainbow. Later (1547) he published a paraphrase of the so-called Aristotelian ``Mechanica'' and a work on calendar reform (1578). His efforts as an educator extended to literary criticism and deportment. This is a well executed article. Unfortunately, there will be no more from the author, who passed away before this one was printed.
0 references