No label defined (Q5587057)
From MaRDI portal
!
This is the item page for this Wikibase entity, intended for internal use and editing purposes. Please use the normal view instead:
scientific article; zbMATH DE number 3305776
| Language | Label | Description | Also known as |
|---|---|---|---|
| default for all languages | No label defined |
||
| English | No label defined |
scientific article; zbMATH DE number 3305776 |
Statements
1965
0 references
history
0 references
0.7466578483581543
0 references
0.691303014755249
0 references
A welcome photo-reprint of Brewster's classical account of the life of the doyen of British science: one which, despite its rapid obsolescence (in face of the flood of recent Newtonian scholarship) and its outmoded canons of Victorian respectability, remains essentially unsuperseded. In comparison, L. T. More's 1934 attempt at an eclectic study seems feeble and myopic, F. E. Manuel's more recent (1968) psychological ``Portrait'' far-fetched and seriously ahistorical, while both betray a deep-seated ignorance of mathematical and scientific technicalities. Brewster's ``Memoirs'', together with Joseph Edleston's ``Synoptical View of Isaac Newton's Life'' (pp. xxi--lxxx of his ``Correspondence of Newton and Cotes'', London, 1850; reprinted 1969) and Ferdinand Rosenberger's ``Isaac Newton and seine physikalischen Prinzipien'' (Leipzig, 1895), continue to be required reading for the Newtonian student. Brewster's own interests lay predominantly in experimental optics and, more generally, in popularising contemporary physics for the new mass reading public created by universal education in nineteenth-century England (he combined both in his invention of the kaleidoscope). We will not be surprised that, though he supports certain traditions (such as Newton's firm theoretical rejection of the feasibility of an achromatic compound lens) whose basis in documented fact is now seen to be very slim, Brewster's chapters on Newton's optical discoveries are his best, dealing firmly and knowledgeably with Newton's insights and experiments on the refraction and diffraction of light, as recorded in his letters and notebooks made available by the Earl of Portsmouth for the first time. For straightforwardly biographical information Brewster relied somewhat uncritically on the anecdotes gathered in jackdaw fashion by Newton's nephew (by marriage) John Conduitt (now mostly in King's College, Cambridge, Keynes 129/130), both directly, and also indirectly through Fontanelle (1728), Turnor (1806) and others; but he generously lards them with numerous colourful extracts from Newton's works, correspondence and papers. In this amalgam he effectively created the received view of Newton's long life, and its tripartite division into his Woolsthorpe (1642--61), Cambridge (1661--96) and London (1696--1726 0. S.) periods, though unable to resolve the many indiscrepancies and inconsistencies in the secondary documents on which he based the heart of his account: these have continued to bedevil Newton's would-be biographer to the present day. Brewster is at his best when (for instance, in the case of the drawn-out dispute between Newton and Flamsteed during 1694--1711) extant letters allow him to piece together a detailed narrative account from primary sources rather than from conventional anecdote. In tracing the historical evolution of Newton's researches into dynamics and its application in planetary and lunar theory Brewster again drew heavily on collected reminiscences (Demoivre, 1727; Pemberton, 1728; Whiston, 1749) but was also able to benefit from the more solidly based researches of Stephen Peter Rigaud ``Historical Essay on the `Principia'\,`'' (Oxford, 1838) and Edleston (1850); however, he made no attempt at a critical examination of the ``Principia'' itself, restricting himself to a popular précis of the theory of universal inverse-square gravitation in the style of Whewell's ``History of the Inductive Sciences'' (London, 1837). Brewster's account of Newton's mathematical development (Vol. 1, pp. 21--25; Vol. 2, pp. 7--22) is jejune and least satisfactory of all, being narrowly based on memoranda drawn up for Conduitt by Demoivre (original now in private possession and William Jones (now ULC. Add. 3960.2) without any attempt to repair their inadequacies: from the first the incredible anecdote that Newton scrawled in the margins of his copy of Descartes' ``Geometrie'' the repeated phrase ``Error, non est Geom.'' has passed into popular mythology, while Brewster perpetuates the confusion in the latter between the ``1671 tract'' and the ``Geometria Analytica'' (which are one and the same treatise). In contrast to such inaptitudes his account of the calculus priority dispute with the Leibnizians during 1712--21 (Vol. 2, pp. 36--83, 282--300) is, particularly in its discussion (founded on still unpublished correspondence with Varignon, Johann Bernoulli and others) of the period after Leibniz' death (November 1716), unsurpassed. The present facsimile is well reproduced on good paper from a clean copy of the 1855 edition. (An extensively annotated copy, corrected by J. C. Adams and H. R. Luard for deposit with the Cambridge Portsmouth papers in 1888, is now ULC. Adv. c. 76.1/2.) In his short introduction to the reprint R. S. Westfall outlines Brewster's scientific career and interests, and accurately stresses his debt to previous accounts in the ``Biographie Britannica'' (1760) and by Biot in the ``Biographie Universelle'' (1822), but fails to mention J. G. de Chaufepié's pioneering article in his ``Nouveau Dictionnnaire Historique et Critique'' (Amsterdam, 1753, 3: Section N, pp. 35--64).
0 references