No label defined (Q5695960)

From MaRDI portal

!

This is the item page for this Wikibase entity, intended for internal use and editing purposes. Please use the normal view instead:

scientific article; zbMATH DE number 2212542
Language Label Description Also known as
default for all languages
No label defined
    English
    No label defined
    scientific article; zbMATH DE number 2212542

      Statements

      0 references
      7 October 2005
      0 references
      concept
      0 references
      conceptual system
      0 references
      incommensurability
      0 references
      comparability
      0 references
      extension
      0 references
      development of concepts
      0 references
      transparent intensional logic
      0 references
      In his previous monograph [``Concepts and objects'', Acta Philos. Fenn. 63, Helsinki (1998)], \textit{P. Materna} developed a theory of concepts based on Transparent Intensional Logic (TIL) founded by \textit{P. Tichý} [The foundations of Frege's logic. Berlin: Walter de Gruyter (1988; Zbl 0671.03001); Collected papers in logic and philosophy. Praha: Filosofia. Dunedin: University of Otago Press (2004)]. A short chapter of the book was devoted to conceptual systems, a topic highly interesting from various logical and philosophical points of view. Materna's new book, here under review, is a continuation of this research. Chapter 1 provides a revised recapitulation of Materna's theory of concepts conceived as abstract procedures known as TIL (closed) constructions which are algorithmically structured entities. This procedural theory of concepts makes it possible to deal with a vast variety of semantic problems, in particular to develop a theory of meaning that is immune to Quinean attacks on the very notion of meaning. What is important is that meaning is defined independently of the notions of synonymy and analyticity (p. 8) and thus the famous definitional circle Quine described in his ``Two dogmas of empiricism'' [\textit{W. V. Quine}, in: S. Sarkar (ed.), Decline and obsolescence of logical empiricism. Carnap vs. Quine and the critics. Edited and with introductions by Sahotra Sarkar. New York, NY: Garland Publishing, Inc. Readings in Philosophy. Science and Philosophy in the Twentieth Century. Basic Works of Logical Empiricism. 5, 18--41 (1996; Zbl 0938.03527)] is broken. Materna explains the principles of (what he calls) logical analysis of natural language which follows compositionality and anti-contextualism, and advocates the idea of a language being a code. Having defined concepts and discussed some notions such as homonymy, vagueness, compositionality, etc., in Chapter 2 Materna develops his theory of conceptual systems. First he takes into account conceptual systems simpliciter, i.e., without considering their connections to languages, and then he adds considerations about conceptual systems and languages. Briefly, a conceptual system is determined by a chosen set of primitive concepts (ontology) from which an infinite set of composed concepts can be created. Two kinds of conceptual systems are considered, namely mathematical and empirical conceptual systems, and some properties and relations of conceptual systems are defined. From the point of view of philosophy of science the most important achievements are presented in the concluding Chapters 3 and 4. Questions like the possibility of comparing conceptual systems according to their expressive power defined as the set of problems that can be formulated within the system, decomposition of systems and incommensurability problems are dealt with here. This is a book rich in content. There are many interesting considerations, such as those regarding development of concepts, as well as many provocative thoughts deserving attention, e.g., the idea that there are synthetic concepts a priori. Together with his previous monograph it presents Materna's important and original contribution to the investigation of concepts. Everyone interested in logic and semantics should read both of them. Concluding, we can also recommend an elaborate review of the book written by \textit{M. Zouhar} and published in Log. Log. Philos. 14, 199--226 (2005).
      0 references

      Identifiers