On Positive Law Problems in the Class of Locally Graded Groups

From MaRDI portal





A group \(G\) is said to satisfy `a finite disjunction of positive relations' if there exists a finite set of positive relations \(S=\{u_i(x,y)=v_i(x,y)\), \(i=1,2,\dots,m\}\) such that every pair of elements in \(G\) satisfies some relation in \(S\). \textit{M. Boffa} [in C. R. Acad. Sci., Paris, Sér. I 303, 587-589 (1986; Zbl 0619.03026)] posed the question: Problem 1. If a group satisfies a finite disjunction of positive relations, does it satisfy a positive law? A group \(G\) is called `\(n\)-collapsing' if for any \(n\)-element subset \(S\subseteq G\), the inequality \(|S^n|<n^n\) holds. A group is called `collapsing' if it is \(n\)-collapsing for some \(n\). \textit{A. Shalev} [in J. Algebra 157, No. 1, 51-62 (1993; Zbl 0814.20023)] posed the following question: Problem 2. Does every collapsing group satisfy a positive law? Let \(G^\omega\) denote the Cartesian product of countably many copies of \(G\) indexed by the natural numbers \(\mathbb{N}\). Let \(G^*\) denote the ultrapower of \(G\) modulo a fixed nonprincipal ultrafilter over the natural numbers (i.e., the image of \(G^\omega\) with respect to the congruence defined by a nonprincipal ultrafilter). The following question was posed by \textit{M. Boffa} [in Lond. Math. Soc. Lect. Note Ser. 244, 134-143 (1997; Zbl 0945.03053)]: Problem 3. Suppose that \(G^*\) contains no free non-Abelian subsemigroup. Does \(G^\omega\) also contain no free non-Abelian subsemigroups? If \(G\) does not contain a free non-Abelian semigroup, then it is said that \(G\) is a \(\setminus\!\!\!\!{\mathcal F}\)-group. In such a group every pair of elements satisfies some positive relation \(u(x,y)=v(x,y)\), which depends on the pair. If for some \(n\) all these relations are of degree \(\leq n\), then it is said that \(G\) is a `\(\setminus\!\!\!\!{\mathcal F}\)-group of bound \(n\)'. The main interesting result of the paper under review is: Theorem 2. Problems 1-3 are equivalent to the question: Does every \(\setminus\!\!\!\!{\mathcal F}\)-group satisfy a positive law? So far all of these four problems are open, and the authors in Theorem 3 of the paper under review give a positive answer to the latter problem (so in view of Theorem 2, to all four problems) in the class of locally graded groups (i.e., groups in which every nontrivial finitely generated subgroup has a proper subgroup of finite index). Theorem 3. Every locally graded \(\setminus\!\!\!\!{\mathcal F}\)-group \(G\) of bound \(n\) satisfies a positive law. The authors end the paper by quoting a question posed by Shirshov in 1963 whether every \(n\)-Engel group satisfies a positive law; and give a positive answer to this question in the class of locally graded groups in Theorem 4 of the paper under review. There is a misprint in the paragraph before Problem S of the paper, where ``\(n<4\) should read ``\(n>4\).











This page was built for publication: On Positive Law Problems in the Class of Locally Graded Groups

Report a bug (only for logged in users!)Click here to report a bug for this page (MaRDI item Q3155517)