Boethius of Dacia (1270s) and Radulphus Brito (1290s) on the universal sign `every'

DOI10.1007/S11787-014-0112-6MaRDI QIDQ2354876zbMATH OpenOpenAlexFDO

Authors Ana María Mora-Márquez

Publication date 27 July 2015

Published in Logica Universalis (Search for Journal in Brave)

Full work available at URL https://doi.org/10.1007/s11787-014-0112-6

zbMATH Keywords

Boethius of Daciamedieval logicRadulphus Britouniversal quantifier

Mathematics Subject Classification ID

History of mathematics in Late Antiquity and medieval Europe (01A35) History of mathematical logic and foundations (03-03)

Review text

This paper contains an analysis about the treatment of the universal quantifier in medieval logic, in particular in the works of Boethius of Dacia and Radulphus Brito. Its aim is in fact to focus on the interpretation given by these two late-13th century Parisian masters, a topic that is considered by the author as neglected so far in the literature. According to her view, Boethius and Radulphus give a priority to the linguistic and grammatical interpretation of the universal quantifier with respect to the logical one, in contrast to the treatment by William of Sherwood and Peter of Spain. In such treatment, ``every is rather regarded as a relational disposition determining a universal relation of attribution between the subject and the predicate. Brito, in contrast, tells us ``that the general and primary intention underlying the invention of `every' is the distribution of the common noun over its particular instances, which is the function given to it in the theoretical grammar (p. 202). One thing left to explain is the nature of such possible particular instances. The last part of the paper discusses in fact this problem, showing how these instances are to Brito primarily those existing at present time. This problem is related to the discussion about the admissibility of inferring the truth of individual and particular statements from that of universal propositions, and therefore the corresponding opinions of Brito and Boethius on this subject are analyzed.

Recommendations

• When the world is not enough: medieval ways to deal with the lack of referents
• Medieval logic
• Multiple quantification and the use of special quantifiers in early sixteenth century logic
• Supposition as quantification versus supposition as global quantificational effect
• scientific article; zbMATH DE number 48366

Cited in

(2)

• Some 15th and early 16th century logicians on the quantification of categorical sentences
• When the world is not enough: medieval ways to deal with the lack of referents

This page was built for publication: Boethius of Dacia (1270s) and Radulphus Brito (1290s) on the universal sign `every'

Report a bug (only for logged in users!)Click here to report a bug for this page (MaRDI item Q2354876)