scientific article; zbMATH DE number 428979
The book bearing a very promising title contains eleven chapters: Overview, Conceptions of energy, The abstract concept of energy, Absolute temperature and the fundamental relationships of thermodynamics: The question of inerrancy, The terminology of system behavior, Equilibrium: In mechanical and thermodynamic system, The pressure scale and pressure- volume work, Multiphase reactions: In coal conversion processing, Competing reactions and catalysis: In the gasification of coal and lignite, Energy functions, Equilibrium, and Catalysis, A note of the representation of reaction equilibria. The title of the book inspires an alternative concept of thermodynamics may be developed. In the preface the author writes: ``The scheme of things is first to present the fundamental concept for energy at its most abstract and rigorous level. and ``The ... approach ... is intended to uncover the nuances of thermodynamics, the subtleties that enter into the attempt to describe mathematically the behavior of thermodynamic systems by less than perfect means.. The main idea is that ``theory must be based upon and correlated to the observations and results of experiment, and not the invers, as so often presented (p. 5). Unfortunately, this program cannot be realized in general. An example: If the Joule-Thomson coefficient \(M(T,P)\) (p. 14) has been obtained by measurements as a function of temperature \(T\) and pressure \(P\), one has to know that the enthalpy \(H(T,P)\) is constant during the measurement. The author writes \(dT/dP\), an expression which does not have a fixed value unless constraints are imposed (here: isenthalpic). Therefore theoretical concepts are needed to interpret measurements. Here the isenthalpy of the measurement of the Joule-Thomson coefficient ensures the existence of an integrating factor belonging to the differential equation induced by measurement \((dT/dP)(\text{isenthalpic})=M(T,P)\), which results in the differential equation \(dH(t,P)=0\) for the enthalpy. Typically the author makes a mistake in transferring this idea to the exploitation of a Gay-Lussac-type experiment in an isolated system (p. 39): In this experiment \(dT/dV\) (\(V\)=volume) should be measured, i.e. \(dV\) is not identically zero and therefore contradictory the system cannot be isolated. If the isolation is cancelled, then the pressure is held constant during the experiment and not the internal energy as it does in isolated systems. Because of the isolation \(dT=0\) (adiabatic) and \(dV=0\) (isochoric) are enforced and there is no way to measure the internal energy by these kinds of experiments directly. Consequently the generalization of the concept on page 47 fails, and the author's philosophy -- first experiments, then theoretical concepts -- breaks down. Additionally not only philosophically ill-posed problems can be found in the book, but also strange physical statements: ``..., entropy is the irreversible energy change divided by the absolute temperature. (p. 3), ``It can be argued ... that deductive (and inductive) reasoning is an illusion. (p. 7) and ``In thermodynamics, the two principal variables are temperature and pressure. Volume is a dependent variable by virtue of the equation of state. (p. 13 and 125). The criterion for irreversibility on page 157 (second formula) is wrong in the given formulation. Concerning ``Limits and Validity announced in the title, they are often generated by mistakes as the last two equations on page 64 and the first one on page 65 show. Finally, the question arises why the editor or the editorial board of ``Advances in Thermodynamics agreed to publish such a week contribution.
- Analytic continuation of asymptotic formulas and axiomatics of thermodynamics and semithermodynamics
- scientific article; zbMATH DE number 7447621 (Why is no real title available?)
- An analytical mechanics approach to the first law of thermodynamics and construction of a variational hierarchy
- NONEQUILIBRIUM NONDISSIPATIVE THERMODYNAMICS — A NEW FIELD OF MODERN THERMODYNAMICS
This page was built for publication:
Report a bug (only for logged in users!)Click here to report a bug for this page (MaRDI item Q3137757)