scientific article; zbMATH DE number 3858790

From MaRDI portal
Publication:3328202





[For the entire collection see Zbl 0527.00040.] The divisibility of commodities is a normal assumption for demonstrating the existence of a competitive equilibrium. The first aim of the paper is to show that the indivisibility invalidates many properties of a competitive economy. The second aim is to determine a competitive pseudoequilibrium in order to show that a convergence on it is not assured by increasing the number of agents and the amount of commodities. A preliminary methodology question, which is not so evident in the analysis of an economy with divisible commodities, involves defining the homogeneity of commodities. Normally the economic homogeneity of commodities is based on a physical and/or psychological test, on the implicit assumption that physical and/or psychological homogeneity necessarily implies the existence of a unique price for each of the commodity units. Since different prices can be associated to commodities considered perfect substitutes by all agents (as will be shown by Example C), we treat indivisible commodities as unique, i.e. commodities of which there is only one unit. After having defined the competitive equilibrium for an economy with unique commodities, Example A illustrates a case of absence of a competitive equilibrium, though the initial allocation of commodities is a Pareto optimum: in this case, consequently, we have a Pareto optimum which is not a competitive equilibrium. Example B shows the possible absence of a competitive equilibrium also for an economy where there are divisible commodities together with unique ones. Example C considers the case of a competitive equilibrium for an economy with unique ones. Example C considers the case of a competitive equilibrium for an economy with unique commodities where different prices are assigned to two commodities which are perfect substitutes for all agents (one of these commodities is exchanged and the other remains unexchanged): moreover, if a same price for these two commodities were imposed, no competitive equilibrium would result. Example D shows that a competitive equilibrium is not necessarily a Pareto optimum. In the second part of the paper a competitive pseudoequilibrium is introduced for an economy with unique commodities by making the economy convex and closing it in a certain way. This pseudoequilibrium allows us to define, for economies with indivisible commodities, a degree of disequilibrium allows us to define, for economies with indivisible commodities, a degree of disequilibrium as the minimal value of the excess demands (taken with their absolute values) corresponding to the pseudoequilibria price vectors. Two examples are given where the degree of disequilibrium remains constant when the economy grows: the first with two agents and an increasing number of unique commodities, and the second with an increasing number of agents and commodities.











This page was built for publication:

Report a bug (only for logged in users!)Click here to report a bug for this page (MaRDI item Q3328202)