scientific article; zbMATH DE number 3877126

From MaRDI portal
Publication:3342399





It appears that for the past thirty years C. I. Staicu has been single- handedly developing what he calls general dimensional analysis and applying it to the analysis of data in a variety of physics and engineering problems. Dimensional analysis is the process of finding the proper exponents on variables in a physical relation. This process is not purely mathematical but is a mixture of heuristic reasoning, algebraic simplification, and experimentation. It follows that this book is not a mathematics book; there are no mathematical definitions, theorems, or proofs presented. Clearly the book is not aimed at an audience of mathematicians. The goal seems to be to sell the author's method, which he calls general dimensional analysis, to those who have been using other methods. A large part of the book consists of physical examples which illustrate the several methods. In one section (22.4 Comparison with the Analytical Method), the topic is the flow of heat during vapor condensation. The analytic method yields a formula for the mean heat transfer coefficient in terms of other quantities by solving simultaneously a set of differential equations which arise from more elementary physical relations. Restricted dimensional analysis is said to yield a less explicit formula which can be made more explicit only by using experimental data. And finally, general dimensional analysis is applied by writing down a relation in the desired variables with unknown exponents and then using dimensional homogeneity to obtain a homogeneous system of linear equations in those exponents. The Rule of general dimensional analysis is that the solution of this system having positive, integral, minimum values is the correct choice of exponents. The author points out an example at the end (25.2 Relations that do not check) where his method fails. But there is no discussion of why it fails and there is no attempt to classify the situations where the method is guaranteed to work.











This page was built for publication:

Report a bug (only for logged in users!)Click here to report a bug for this page (MaRDI item Q3342399)