scientific article; zbMATH DE number 3875268

From MaRDI portal
Publication:3342565





[For the entire collection see Zbl 0511.00005.] We shall be concerned with the results obtained by \textit{J. R. Steel} and \textit{R. van Wesep} [Trans. Am. Math. Soc. 272, 67-85 (1982; Zbl 0528.03033)], they show the consistency of ZFC together with \(\omega_ 2\) is the second uniform indiscernible and the nonstationary ideal on \(\omega_ 1\) is \(\omega_ 2\)-saturated. The latter solves a well known problem within the theory of saturated ideals. For their result, Steel and Van Wesep needed to assume the consistency of \(ZF+AD+{\mathbb{R}}-AC,\) where \({\mathbb{R}}-AC\) is the axiom of choice for families indexed by the reals. This theory is substantially stronger than \(ZF+AD.\) We reduce the assumption needed to just the consistency of \(ZF+AD.\) As we have suggested their method is to start with a model of \(ZF+AD+{\mathbb{R}}-AC\) and then construct a forcing extension in which ZFC holds. The forcing is mild enough so that in the generic extension, \(\omega_ 2\) is the second uniform indiscernible and the nonstationary ideal on \(\omega_ 1\) is \(\omega_ 2\)-saturated. Basically we simply show that \(ZF+AD+V=L({\mathbb{R}})\) suffices to carry out their forcing arguments. We also isolate a single combinatorial principle which in ZFC implies both that \(\omega_ 2\) is the second uniform indiscernible and that the nonstationary ideal on \(\omega_ 1\) is \(\omega_ 2\)-saturated. This principle we show holds in the generic extension. The point of this is twofold. First it offers a means to those uninterested in AD for mining the combinatorial riches of this model and second it suggests that a theory weaker than AD may suffice for these consistency results. Finally we extend the results of Steel and Van Wesep to show that if \(ZF+AD\) is consistent then so is \(ZFC+MA+\neg CH +\) the nonstationary ideal on \(\omega_ 1\) is \(\omega_ 2\)-saturated.











This page was built for publication:

Report a bug (only for logged in users!)Click here to report a bug for this page (MaRDI item Q3342565)