scientific article; zbMATH DE number 3891320

From MaRDI portal
Publication:3347847





[For the entire collection see Zbl 0544.00004.] This paper presents a definition of an intertheoretic relation which is based on G. Ludwig's concept of approximate embedding. If two theories are characterized by the same vocabulary, but different laws, it makes sense to ask in which sense the two sets of solutions (or models) of the respective laws are close together. Some simple examples (viz. v.d. Waals/ideal gas law, spherical/plane geometry, Kepler's/Galileo's law of free fall) are analysed in short to show that usually the sets of solutions are in tangent contact with respect to some identification map. This intuitive picture is formally developed into the definition of proximorphisms and a degree of tangency \(\lambda\) . As a more advanced example, the relation between classical and relativistic spacetime is analyzed in terms of tangent embeddings, and proximorphisms with \(\lambda =2\) are constructed in this case. So far, tangent embedding is purely mathematically defined and typically generates a symmetric relation between reductive pairs of theories. In order to account for the asymmetry between reduced and reducing theories the author considers physical observations, sets of data, and blurred sets of data corresponding to deviations between observation and theoretical prediction. For the full concept of tangent embedding it will be required that the difference in the degree of blurring (or error) between the two theories can be explained by the error of embedding. This is a quantitative refinement of the usual qualitative conditions on the domains of empirical successes and failures.











This page was built for publication:

Report a bug (only for logged in users!)Click here to report a bug for this page (MaRDI item Q3347847)