scientific article; zbMATH DE number 3968555

From MaRDI portal
Publication:3735683





This is a carefully written, comprehensive and enjoyable history of calculating prodigies. Among other things, it should go far in correcting the popular belief that all calculating prodigies are idiot savants with an outstanding talent for mental calculation but are otherwise mentally retarded. Such prodigies have existed, but some such prodigies have been brilliant. For example, Euler and Gauss appear to have been calculating prodigies. The mathematician Alexander Craig Aitken (1895- 1967) was certainly one, as the author shows in Chapter 31. George Parker Bidder (1806-1878) was an outstanding civil engineer (Chapter 23). Wim Klein (born 1912) did valuable work for physicists at CERN until he was replaced by computers (p. 295-296). Hans Eberstark (born 1929) is a simultaneous translator for a number of pairs of languages (p. 309). And so on. In Part 3 of his book, the author gives biographies of not only contemporary prodigies but also the legendary calculators: Jedediah Buxton (1702-1772), Thomas Fuller (a black, c. 1710-1790), Zerah Colburn (1804-1840), Jacques Inaudi (1867-1950), and others who have often been cited by psychologists, essayists, and others (frequently enough in order to make a point about the inferiority of doing mathematics). Part 2 of the book contains a treatment of the methods used by the calculators. It appears, for example, that there are two kinds of calculators, visual and auditory (Chapter 1), and that nearly all auditory calculators multiply from left to right. Multiplication, decimalization of fractions, extraction of roots, raising to powers, factoring, calculating logarithms, reducing integers to sums of four squares, and day-date calculations are considered in separate chapters. In Part 1, the author treats the psychology of mental calculation, including factors of age, intelligence, sex, heredity, consciousness, memory, use of mnemonics, and calculating times and extent. Among other things, he makes the interesting hypothesis that one of the reasons for the superiority of prodigies at calculation is that they have tapped some of the same unconscious capacity that underlies speech (p. 25). He notes that statements by calculating prodigies are emphatic on the sequential nature of mental calculation (p. 34). (This might seem to preclude parallel processing, but then part of the processing is unconscious.) This book is full of interesting facts and insights about prodigious calculators. It should appeal not only to specialists (mathematicians, psychologists, computer scientists, philosophers, etc.) who want to use such calculators to make or unmake a point, but to just anyone who has ever wondered how calculating prodigies operate.











This page was built for publication:

Report a bug (only for logged in users!)Click here to report a bug for this page (MaRDI item Q3735683)