scientific article; zbMATH DE number 3989315

From MaRDI portal
Publication:3752360





This is an English translation of a French work of 1975, with additional material. It is valuable for English-speaking readers to see how a different but related tradition approaches problems both began to formulate at about the same time; it may usefully be compared to the Davidson program, to \textit{L. Goddard} and \textit{R. Routley} [The logic of significance and context (1973; Zbl 0302.02004)] and to the grammatical section of \textit{A. R. Anderson} and \textit{N. D. Belnap}'s Entailment (1975; Zbl 0323.02030). Gardies is less tightly argued: for example, in formulating the three conjuncts into which Russell analysed a definite description, he uses the person in a circular way in two of them, p. 182; and his statement that the language of science contains no reference either to interlocutors or to the time of utterance, p. 126, which ignores the citation of fellow-workers (interlocutors) and the scientific use of present, ago (see Popper, ed. Schilpp, 1974, p. 1143). On the other hand, he takes grammatical moods (including optative, hortative, etc.) more seriously than either indicative-centric logicians or the speech-act theorists who pay little attention to grammar. He is more aware of connections to other social sciences, and his historical perspective is complementary to the English-language tradition.












This page was built for publication:

Report a bug (only for logged in users!)Click here to report a bug for this page (MaRDI item Q3752360)