scientific article; zbMATH DE number 1003113
Without neglecting the Geometria, the article concentrates on Cavalieri's minor writings, which enables the author to trace Cavalieri's attitudes to the relation between geometry and knowledge of physical nature and to the various interpretations of the planetary system -- and, not least, the evolution of these attitudes. In certain respects, it turns out, Cavalieri believed more strongly than Galileo in the geometrization of nature; in others, however, he was a genuine Platonist (in strong contrast to Galileo and other presupposed Platonists of early seventeenth-century science, who are better described as ``Archimedists) and argues with explicit reference to Plato that nature is only an imperfect imitation of the perfection of geometry, and that it was therefore a mistake to take observation or amazement over nature as the starting points of philosophy. His polemics against Guldin's rejection of Kepler's and Cavalieri's own infinitesimal methods and against Guldin's alternative use of his unproven ``theorem (supported by Aristotelian philosophical principles) is shown to fit this stance. In spite of Cavalieri's admiration for Galileo he is also shown often to have been closer to Kepler, and to have understood the novelty and importance both of Kepler's ``physical astronomy and of his elliptic orbits -- another respect in which Cavalieri's position was fairly unique. A seeming retraction of all Keplerian and Copernican sympathies in a work written in 1642 -- thus after the Galileo trial -- is analyzed and shown to be ``a classical example of honest dissimulation which uses dialectic and the disputative style to drive the adversary into absurd conclusions (pp. 100f). Though this was achieved by indirect means there were thus good reasons that the work was only published posthumously in censured and domesticated form. For the entire collection see [Zbl 0842.00030].
This page was built for publication:
Report a bug (only for logged in users!)Click here to report a bug for this page (MaRDI item Q4335066)