scientific article; zbMATH DE number 1006226

From MaRDI portal
Publication:4335825





Strong links existed between school teachers and University professors in Prussia (see the articles by \textit{R. Tobies} [ibid., 117-130 (1996; Zbl 0907.01032)], and by \textit{G. Schubring} [ibid., 19-28 (1996; Zbl 0907.01028)]). Grassmann in 1827-1831 missed mathematics in Berlin: Enno Dirksen, Martin Ohm and Jabbo Oltmanns were not wonderful, and Dirichlet had just arrived. Details of Grassmann's life and study are scattered through the whole of this book, and few appear in this article, especially necessary details of family, wife, children, names and dates (these would help in Schubring's [loc. cit.] article: Hermann was one of 12, and had at least 5 children). Essentially Hermann followed in his father Justus's footsteps, ending his life succeeding his father at school in Stettin. The only comparison made in the article is a brief one with Steiner. There are many sources for comparison: here are three [\textit{Julius Lange}, Jacob Steiners Lebensjahre in Berlin, 1821-1863, Programm Friedrich Werdersche Oberrealschule Berlin, 1899; \textit{Josef Schnippenkötter}, Ohm in Köln. Beiträge zur Geschichte der Mathematik und Physik zu Beginn des 19. Jahrhunderts, in: Georg Simon Ohm als Lehrer und Forscher in Köln 1817-1826. Festschrift zur 150. Wiederkehr seines Geburtstags. Herausgegeben vom Kölnischen Geschichtsverein in Verbindung mit der Universität und dem Staatlichen Dreikönigs-Gymnasium in Köln, Köln: Kommissionsverlag J. P. Bachem, 1939, pp. 63-172; \textit{Gert Schubring}, Jahrb. Überblicke Math. 1985, Math. Surv. 18, 143-173 (1985; Zbl 0559.01016). Schwartze judges Grassmann as a teacher of subjects other than mathematics, as a teacher of mathematics, and as a person: for the last he was always friendly, good-natured, diligent; as a teacher of other subjects he had a good reputation, with good discipline, suitable methods, especially for linguistics; but as a teacher of mathematics he aimed too high, he taught for the most gifted in the class, with no adjustment or relation to the level of the less gifted, with general results rather than examples at a lower level, without drill or repetition, and poor discipline: inattention, bad behaviour; and methods of teaching unsuitable for mathematics and the bulk of the students. His mathematics textbooks lacked exercises (referred to another's book), the presentation was abstract and axiomatic, there was an abundance of proofs, and the material was demanding. Grassmann applied for a University post three times, in 1847, 1862, and was proposed in 1868: the Minister refused the first time on a report by Kummer, the second time the Minister pointed out the severely reduced salary, and Greifswald refused the third time. His fate was similar to Georg Ohm's, for similar reasons. For the entire collection see [Zbl 0853.00027].











This page was built for publication:

Report a bug (only for logged in users!)Click here to report a bug for this page (MaRDI item Q4335825)