scientific article; zbMATH DE number 1021610
This is an unusual book combining the history of mathematics and the history of art. Moreover, it is written not only with erudition in both fields, but with a light humor which is attractive. It is also copiously illustrated, not only with mathematical diagrams but with (black-and-white) reproductions of illustrative paintings and illustrative diagrams from Renaissance texts as well. Briefly the book tells the history of a part of ``practical mathematics, namely perspective in geometry, from the time of Brunelleschi (1377-1446) and Piero della Francesca (1412-1492) until its subsuming into the projective geometry of Girard Desargues (1591-1661), which, except for Blaise Pascal (1623-1662) and Philippe de la Hire (1640-1718), was then forgotten by mathematicians until the beginning of the nineteenth century. It was certainly no accident that de la Hire's father was a painter who champtioned Desargues' methods. Piero della Francesca, acclaimed as an important painter, sometimes gets a few insignificant words in histories of mathematics, but nothing more. Actually he seems to have written the first treatise on ``perspective for painting, and two other surviving texts by him are on the abacus and the Platonic solids. This last seems to contain the first ``rediscovery of the Archimedean solids. Luca Pacioli (1445-1514), who is mentioned significantly in histories of mathematics, reprinted some of Piero's work as though it were his own -- though intellectual property rights were vague in the fifteenth century, there were those who complained. Piero saw his work in the already established tradition of ``Euclidean optics, but it is a comprehensive treatise on what might be called practical perspective (e.g. points and lines are as seen by the eye instead of as by the intellect alone). But as already indicated, there were other predecessors and there is even an apparently accurate perspective illustration by Giotto. Brunelleschi, the architect of the famous cathedral dome in Florence, apparently discovered some sort of ``perspective rule around 1413, though what it was is not now known, and there were other fifteenth century constructions for perspective. This book discusses the mathematical accuracy or inaccuracy of various attempts to render perspective from the early Renaissance until the time of Desargues. It deals not only with painting but with problems of stage design and architecture as well. This is done in tandem with a discussion of the treatise on perspective both ``practical and ``theoretical. A point not often considered by non-artists is that in all this work the ``ideal viewing point of the spectator also needs to be considered. ``Practical perspective as much ``practical mathematics was gradually absorbed into the learned tradition. Artists and craftsmen became relegated to a different social class from mathematicians. Desargues' work had been composed for Mersenne's circle and provided a unified mathematical approach to previously separately treated cases (since the time of Appolonius). It was through Mersenne that Pascal and Descartes learned of Desargues' work. This was neglected by most mathematicians for as long as it was, partly because of a misunderstanding as to the importance of \textit{method} as opposed to individual results (``practical mathematics had always stressed the form of particular results), and partly because of Desargues' undeniably very difficult style. Nevertheless other mathematicians also took an interest in perspective. Newton apparently read La Hire and Brook Taylor wrote a book on perspective (which introduced the term ``vanishing point). By this time the mathematics of perspective was too elementary for mathematicians and had reached a completion for artists -- even \textit{trompe l'oeil} techniques were well-known. The final illustration in this book is Hogarth's well-known humorous engraving \textit{Perspective absurdities} which was originally the frontispiece for a work on perspective derived from Taylor's. The Invention of Infinity is a scholarly book written with a delightful sense of humor. It is highly recommended to anyone with an interest in the history of art or of geometry, and especially the two together.
- Boscovich's geometrical principle of continuity, and the ``mysteries of the infinity
- Mathematics and architecture since 1960
- Mathematics in perspective: Desargues, la Hire, le Poîvre
- Cosmogenic pattern language: toward an architectural language based on the cosmogenic patterns of pre-modernism
- Perspective at Palladio's time and its scientific heritage
- Luca Pacioli and perspective. I
- Piero della Francesca, mathematician of the Renaissance
- Luca Pacioli and perspective. II
- Leon Battista Alberti as author of \textit{Hypnerotomachia poliphili}
- The geometry of an art. The history of the mathematical theory of perspective from Alberti to Monge
- Book review of: K. Andersen, Optical illusions in Rome. A mathematical travel guide
- The mathematics of painting: the birth of projective geometry in the Italian Renaissance
- Architecture, mathematics and theology in Raphael's paintings
- Perspective and the plan and elevation technique, in particular in the work by Piero della Francesca
- The debates about the foundations of linear perspecive from Piero della Francesca to Eqnatio Danti: a case of reverse mathematization
- On Kepler's system of conics in \textit{Astronomiae pars optica}
- To Kirsti: `From art history with love' perspective: then and now, and artistic practice
- An unusual \textit{Sacra Conversazione} by Giovanni Bellini
- Desargues' Method of Perspective Its Mathematical Content, Its Connection to Other Perspective Methods and Its Relation to Desargues' Ideas on Projective Geometry
- scientific article; zbMATH DE number 1003116 (Why is no real title available?)
- The geometry of vision. Science, art, didactic
- True grid
- Visual culture and mathematics in the early modern period
- Representation of non-metric concepts of space in architectural design theories
- scientific article; zbMATH DE number 1425653 (Why is no real title available?)
- The eye as a pair of compasses: Viviani's ``geometrical mechanics in support of Brunelleschi's dome
- scientific article; zbMATH DE number 3893135 (Why is no real title available?)
- Optical illusions in Rome. A mathematical travel guide. Translated from the Danish by Viktor Blåsjö
- LE TRACÉ CONTINU DES SECTIONS CONIQUES À LA RENAISSANCE: APPLICATIONS OPTICO-PERSPECTIVES, HÉRITAGE DE LA TRADITION MATHÉMATIQUE ARABE
- A mathematical analysis of Masaccio's \textit{Trinity}
- Piero della Francesca. A mathematician's art
- Federico Commandino and the Latin edition of Apollonius's \textit{Conics} (1566)
- The mathematician Piero della Francesca
- Investigating illusion: Panofsky and others on perspective
- Desargues's perspective theory: a critical interpretation of the fundamental theorem
- Reflections on the relationship between perspective and geometry in the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries
- Giotto and Renaissance perspective
This page was built for publication:
Report a bug (only for logged in users!)Click here to report a bug for this page (MaRDI item Q4340901)