Boole’s mathematical blindness

From MaRDI portal
Publication:4346306





The author raises the question on Boole's motives to use the symbolic methods of the calculus of operations to solve differential equations like \[ (a_2x + b_2)u(x) + (a_1x + b_1)u'(x) + (a_0x + b_0)u(x) = X(x) \] where \(a_i\) and \(b_i\) are constants and \(X(x)\) is a known function. Boole failed to find general solutions, although he had Laplace transforms at hand, the means of choice for rigorous solutions. The author sees the case of a major figure in the history of mathematics ``most anxious to solve a mathematical problem, holding the key to its solution, and quite blind to what it was that he held (p. 514). The author gives two possible reasons for Boole's failure to see the correspondence between symbolic methods and Laplace methods: the first one, technical deficiencies, seems to be of minor importance, the second, main reason is seen in Boole's preoccupations with the ``laws of thought. According to the author Boole did not only want to solve a technical problem in mathematics, but to contribute to a general theory of thought and language. This provoked his failure---reason enough for the author to draw the moral that the terms in which Boole sought to solve his problem should be avoided, because Boole was obviously looking at the wrong place and formulating his problem in a wrong way. Although correct in regard to Boole's problem this conclusion appears to be \textit{historically} blind at least in one eye. The argument presupposes a strange inversion of historical order. The calculus of operations came first, the logical writings are later, designed in the beginning, e.g. in Boole's ``The mathematical analysis of logic (1847), as an application of the calculus of operations. The author fails to consider that the calculus of operations paved the way to a version of modern abstract algebra via the new symbolic logic. A fair historical evaluation should therefore lead to an alternative moral: the calculus of operations shows that mathematical concepts can be fruitful although they do not solve the problems they were designed for. The calculus of operations was a breakthrough for the modern mathematical epistemology.











This page was built for publication: Boole’s mathematical blindness

Report a bug (only for logged in users!)Click here to report a bug for this page (MaRDI item Q4346306)