scientific article; zbMATH DE number 1117971
In the preface the authors define the aims of the book and its audience as follows: ``We have designed and written this book, not as a text for the professional mathematician, but for the general reader who is naturally attracted to mathematics as a great intellectual challenge, and for the special reader whose work requires him to have a deeper understanding of mathematics than he acquired in school. They introduce arithmetic, algebra, graphs of functions, geometry, trigonometry, analytic geometry and calculus. The book surprised this reviewer by total absence of diagrams and pictures. Here is, for example, how the authors introduce decimal digits (pp. 5-6): ``The scale of our point-ordering scheme is set as soon as we choose the first point at some particular distance to the right of 0 and label it with the symbol 1. We may think of this symbol as identifying the first point in this ordering system to the right of 0 or as defining the unit distance measured from 0. Thus the symbol 1 implies a distance-measuring operation which we now use to identify a point as far to the right of 1 as 1 is to the right of 0 and so on. Notice that where we place 1 to the right of 0 is immaterial to our ordering scheme, but once we choose this point, we can assign a symbol to every singular point to the right of 1 (singular in the sense that each such point is at the same distance from its right and left neighbors as 1 is from 0). With this idea in mind, we assign the eight symbols 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9 to the eight similar points to the right of 1. We thus exhaust the ten symbols that we grew up with from our childhood and which, we were taught, are the basis of our number system. [Observe: not just a picture is absent -- the word ``line has not even appeared here -- it comes in the next paragraph!] In the opinion of the reviewer, the book dramatically lacks mathematical culture. Here are but a few examples: 1. (p. 84). ``The importance of reducing an algebraic expression to its simplest form by canceling out common factors is illustrated in the expression \((x^2-y^2)/(x-y)\) if we allow \(x\) to equal \(y\). We then get \(0/0\) which is meaningless. But we obtain a meaningful expression by placing \((x^2-y^2)=(x-y)(x+y)\). The \((x-y)\) in the numerator cancels the \((x-y)\) in the denominator and the fraction is equal to \(2y\) for \(x=y\). [In fact, \((x^2-y^2)/(x-y)\) is NOT equal \((x+y)\) when \(x=y\).] 2. (pp. 108-109). ``\dots{} we consider the following infinite sum \(y= 1+x+x^2+ x^3+\dots \). \([\text{snip}]y= 1/(1-x)\). This is called the sum of the geometric series. This formula gives us the correct value for the sum only if \(x\) is smaller than 1. For values of \(x\) larger than 1 the sum is infinite. For all negative values of \(x\), however, the formula gives us the correct sum. [Thus, the authors apparently believe that for, say, \(x=-2\), the sum \(1+(-2)+ (-2)^2+ (-2)^3+\dots\) converges to \(1/(1- (-2))\).] 3. (p. 92). ``\dots{} we must treat each side [of the equation] equally in any manipulations we perform. Thus, we may add or subtract anything we please to or from one side of the equation if we do the same thing to the other side. This rule applies to all other arithmetic or algebraic operations we may perform on either side of an equation. These operations are multiplying (or dividing), raising to powers, taking roots, and taking logarithms. Other algebraic operations may be applied to both sides of the equation without invalidating it. [Fault in the above should be clear to every student: the solution set can be changed arbitrarily by performing the suggested operations without additional limitations.] 4. (p. 140). ``From the concepts of a point and of distance we now define a straight line as the shortest distance between any two points. [Thus line is defined as a distance!] In the third (!) printing one would expect from Plenum Press a better edited text than the one that puts Fermat in the XVIII century (p. 163); gives no credit to Cantor for his diagonal counting proof (p. 66); uses the word ``integer where the word ``digit must be used (pp. 66, 62); uses terms ``irrational and ``transcendental without defining them (p. 61); states in the definition of the limit of \(\Delta r/\Delta t\) as \(\Delta t\) approaches zero that ``\(\Delta t\) is placed equal to zero; suggests that ``the value of \(\pi\) is now known to about 100 decimal places (p. 178), etc. In the opinion of the reviewer the book is extremely short of rigor. The authors say they ``\textit{deduce} Heron's formula for the area of triangle and the Pythagorean Theorem, where as in reality they just show why those results are \textit{reasonable to conjecture} (pp. 163-168). This shocks the specialist and misleads the unprepared reader into believing that he reads mathematical proofs. Perhaps, this is the goal, as the authors write (p. 165): ``We now deduce another formula for the area of a triangle using very general reasoning and elementary logic. This approach to mathematics is usually discussed by mathematicians as lacking in rigor but it is extremely useful in that it leads one quickly to the desired result. The authors write (p. 137): ``We now know that the Euclidean geometry is a false prophet whose dogma applies to no part of the universe and, indeed, can never be demonstrated as true. It is true that Lobachevsky and Riemann created new geometries that are on equal footing with the Euclidean geometry, but they never declared, as the authors allege, the ``ultimate denial of Euclidean geometry (p. 141). The authors, apparently, are ignorant of Kurt Gödel's `Unprovability' Theorem when they write that ``the axioms must be complete so that all possible theorems that are consistent with the geometry can be proved (p. 142). On the dust jacket it is quoted that ``this book is a must for those who want to find what mathematics is about. This reviewer respectfully disagrees: the book may severely misrepresent to a novice reader what mathematics and mathematical culture are all about.
This page was built for publication:
Report a bug (only for logged in users!)Click here to report a bug for this page (MaRDI item Q4376872)