scientific article; zbMATH DE number 1786470

From MaRDI portal
Publication:4547762





The mere fact that the values given by the most famous Greek astronomer Ptolemy (fl. 150) for the phenomena of precession, inclination of the ecliptic and the position of the solar apogee were fundamentally flawed, and were already noticed to be so even a century or so after Ptolemy and much more so seven centuries later, and the mere fact that later astronomers had a healthy respect for the observational abilities of this giant of an astronomer, all this led to the most incredible investigations in the history of astronomy. Later astronomers found the value of precession to be almost one and half times the value that was recorded in Ptolemy's Almagest, and the inclination of the ecliptic to be almost a full third of a degree less than the value given by Ptolemy, and the solar apogee to be moving rather than fixed as stated by Ptolemy. All these variations called for an explanation. One of the theories that could at once explain the variations in the value of precession and the inclination of the ecliptic was to assume that Ptolemy was right in his own measurements but that these phenomena themselves did not have a fixed value, rather they partook of a motion of their own. That motion was then assumed to be cyclical, like all other motions in the celestial realm, and thus some mechanism had to be concocted in order to explain those same variations. Moreover as the increase or decrease in those values could not be obviously a progressive function of time it was further assumed that the mechanism that produced these variations in the said values must repeat itself in an oscillating fashion that could produce a maximum variation from the time of Ptolemy by some eight degrees. By the time the astronomers of Baghdad came onto the scene, some seven centuries after Ptolemy, the variations between what they could find, even by their own crude observations, and what they could read in Ptolemy's Almagest were so exaggerated that it was no longer possible to accept Ptolemy's values for the said phenomena without question, no matter how much respect Ptolemy had by then acquired in their eyes. Under the circumstances they were faced with two possibilities: Either Ptolemy was simply wrong and his observations were fundamentally flawed and had to be discarded in favor of the newly-found values, and lots of astronomers working in the Islamic civilization believed that to be the case, or that the values given by Ptolemy for what he thought were, like the apogee of the sun, fixed phenomena were indeed not fixed and thus the variations were part of that ever changing aspect of the phenomena themselves. This latter option led to the adoption of a mathematical modeling technique that could account for the variation as a feature of a trepidation phenomenon through which the values of precession and the inclination of the ecliptic could be conceived to oscillate between two extreme values. The astronomers working in Islamic Spain, like their eastern counterparts, tried their hand at the solution of this very problem and at producing their own models of trepidation that could account for this oscillating phenomenon. The article under review, takes up the works of one such thirteenth-century Andalusian astronomer, known as Ibn al-Hā'im (fl. 1205), and analyses in great detail the context of this astronomer's work within other works produced in al-Andalus during the two preceding centuries, and supplies an edition of the Arabic text upon which the analysis is made. For all those who wish to follow one of the most interesting ingenious mathematical devices that were developed specifically to uphold one's own contemporary observations and at the same time explain away the inherited, but different, observations of a trusted by-gone authority, this article will offer a real treat.











This page was built for publication:

Report a bug (only for logged in users!)Click here to report a bug for this page (MaRDI item Q4547762)