scientific article; zbMATH DE number 3993724

From MaRDI portal
Publication:4722173





Let K be an ordered field and let c(K) be its cofinality character. The author calls K 'metareal' if given any bounded subset M of K, whose cardinal number is \(\geq c(K)\), then M has a cluster point in K (relative to the interval topology). Clearly the real field \({\mathbb{R}}\) is metareal. The only Archimedean metareal field is \({\mathbb{R}}\) itself. Since the reviewer did not know of any non-Archimedean metareal fields, he turned quickly to the author's argument, in Sections 4 and 5, in which the author claims that non-Archimedean metareal fields exist. The reviewer was able to follow to the author's reasoning from the beginning of Section 4 to the end of p. 138. There \(R(x_ 1,...,x_ m)=R\in F(x_ j)_{j\in {\mathbb{N}}}=F(X)\), the \(x_ j's\) being indeterminates over an ordered field F. However, at the top of p. 139, R is allowed to be in F(\(\Xi)\)(X), \(\Xi\) being a set of algebraically independent elements over an ordered field F. The author goes on to consider representations of \(\mu\in M\) as \(R(\xi_ 1,...,\xi_ m)\), the \(\xi_ 1,...,\xi_ m's\) being in \(\Xi\). The possible difficulties of doing this can be seen in the following example. Example: Let F be any field, let \(\xi\) be transcendental over F, and let x be an indeterminate over F(\(\xi)\). Let \(R(x)=1/(x-\xi)\), in F(\(\xi)\)(x); however, R(\(\xi)\) is undefined ! Since such undefined expressions may occur on pp. 139-140, the reviewer was unable to verify the correctness of this proof. On the other hand, efforts to find an example of the author's field F(\(\Xi)\) (Section 5), which is not metareal, have not succeeded; although new examples of non- Archimedean fields that are not metareal were found. If non-Archimedean metareal fields do indeed exist, then this is an interesting and possible even an important paper.











This page was built for publication:

Report a bug (only for logged in users!)Click here to report a bug for this page (MaRDI item Q4722173)