scientific article; zbMATH DE number 3330709

From MaRDI portal
Publication:5608739





The aim of this book is to provide an exposition of Frege's thought, particularly with respect to its importance and influence in the development of logicism. Hence after an extensive discussion of the author's own point of view and of Frege's intentions and aims, the book is divided into two main sections. The first is on logical theory in general and considers the ``Begriffsschrift, the fundamentals of a higher order calculus and the paradoxes; the second is on the reduction of arithmetic to logic and includes, among other things, a long discussion of the notion of an axiom, concentrating on a comparison between the views of Frege and Hilbert. Throughout the book there are interesting comparisons between Frege's thought and that of his contemporaries and nineteenth-century predecessors. The whole enterprise is, indeed, a very ambitious and worthwhile project. That it is not as successful as it might be can be illustrated by (and is in large part due to) what seems to be the inability of the author really to see the point of Frege's fundamental position on the philosophy of logic. Every author is entitled to his own point of view, and it is to the author's credit that he states his clearly and unequivocally. He is a formalist after the manner of Hilbert, and his comparisons between Frege and Hilbert generally find the latter on top. According to the author, logicism has two aspects. It is, first, (and is best known as) a doctrine about the foundations of mathematics; as such logicism was concerned with the development of formal systems aiming at a demonstration of the sense in which mathematics can be derived from logic. It is, secondly, a doctrine about logic, ``une doctrine à priori de ce que doit être la logique. The author asserts: ``Cette doctrine a cessé d'être actuelle. But what doctrine exactly? Frege and Russell are abused a good bit for being platonists, for believing that logic is ontology, or, worse yet, cosmology. To the extent that arguments are presented against what the author takes to be Frege's position they tend to rest upon difficulties in the logicist programme for reducing arithmetic to logic and reminders that formal logic has developed considerably since Frege and that people can work out alternative logics. The former considerations are, of course, relevant to the ``actualité of logicism in its first aspect, but the latter simply miss the whole point of Frege's philosophy of logic. He would not be opposed to the study of uninterpreted calculi as such, but they give rise, to no philosophical problems at all and, hence; can provide no solutions to philosophical problems. Indeed, since one can write what one pleases, such putative solutions would be the easiest thing in the world, simply a matter of the dexterity of the pen. But philosophical problems only arise when one considers the possible interpretation of calculi. For logic to be of any philosophical interest it must study calculi with a view to their interpretation. One may refuse to consider the philosophical problems, but they remain with us, as many a naive conventionalism illustrates. There is nothing, then, in this book to make us doubt Frege's fundamental insights about the philosophy of logic, rightly understood. The author gives a rather extensive bibliography of works published through 1964. There is, in fact, every indication that the book at hand was completed in 1964. If so, it is a pity that it had to wait six years for publication; or, if this delay was necessary, one might have used the time to consider material more recently published. In particular a discussion of Frege's ``Nachgelassene Schriften [Nachgelassene Schriften und wissenschaftlicher Briefwechsel. Hamburg: Felix Meiner Verlag (1969; Zbl 0185.00503)] would have been most interesting for the topics of this book since in these writings Frege himself criticizes his own work and finally, in 1924--25, abandons logicism.












This page was built for publication:

Report a bug (only for logged in users!)Click here to report a bug for this page (MaRDI item Q5608739)