No label defined (Q3787968)

From MaRDI portal

!

This is the item page for this Wikibase entity, intended for internal use and editing purposes. Please use the normal view instead:

scientific article; zbMATH DE number 4051556
Language Label Description Also known as
default for all languages
No label defined
    English
    No label defined
    scientific article; zbMATH DE number 4051556

      Statements

      0 references
      1987
      0 references
      overview of deontic logic
      0 references
      adequacy of formal systems
      0 references
      mathematical constructions
      0 references
      paradoxes
      0 references
      obligation
      0 references
      permission
      0 references
      possible worlds models
      0 references
      alethic modal systems
      0 references
      completeness
      0 references
      translatability
      0 references
      logic of norms
      0 references
      The purpose of this book is to provide an overview of deontic logic as it exists today, that is on the one hand reasonably comprehensive and yet on the other hand structured and directed. The task is not an easy one, for the subject can hardly be said to be in a very settled state, nor in a very satisfactory one. There are continuing disagreements about fundamentals, a multitude of ``competing'' systems, no real consensus as to what are the central formal results, and a disappointingly thin development of practical applications. Despite this situation, the author succeeds remarkably well in his enterprise. The material is presented in two main packages. The first, made up of Parts I and II of the book, discusses general questions of the adequacy of formal systems of deontic logic as tools for understanding and assessing normative discourse in ordinary language. The second package, made up of Parts III through VI of the book as well as the long appendix, sets out the mathematical constructions and theorems selected by the author. This arrangement allows the reader to get some general bearings on the subject before plunging into the thicket of formal systems and their properties. On the other hand, it tends to be undertermined by continual use, in the first segment, of forward reference to the second - not only for results and proofs, but also for definitions of terms and concepts. The first package opens with a brief account of the propositional deontic logics with monadic operators for obligation and permission as developed by von Wright and his successors; gives a painstaking exposition of the well-known ``paradoxes'' to which they are exposed; and uses those paradoxes to motivate the introduction of dyadic operators for obligation and permission, e.g. the operator \(O_ AB\) for the obligation of B under the condition A. The author then suggests, following \textit{J. A. van Eck} [``A system of temporally relative modal and deontic predicate logic and its philosophical applications'', Logique Anal. 25, 249-290, 339-381 (1982; Zbl 0549.03004)] that even this formalism is far too impoverished to be of much use for the analysis of normative discourse in real life, and will remain so unless equipped with quantifiers (over various kinds of entity: agents, occasions, perhaps properties and individual or generic acts or possible acts...) and also devices for reasoning about time. However, this perceptive suggestion remains rather isolated from the rest of the book. On the one hand, it is not linked in close analysis with the preceding discussion of the paradoxes, nor with the ``Protagoras puzzle'' with which the book opens - although the author has elsewhere, in a rather inaccessible article, brought out the essential role of time in the latter [``The Protagoras case: an exercise in elementary logic for lawyers'', in: W. Rabinowicz ed., Tankar och Tankefel tillägnade Zalma Puterman, Filosofiska Föreningen, Uppsala, pp. 211-224; also in Annales Acedemiae Regiae Scientiarum Upsaliensis 24, 5-15 (1981-1982), Almqvist and Wiksell, Stockholm]. Nor is the insight put to work in the formal material of the second segment of the book. There the author concentrates on a fine technical analysis of a collection of monadic and dyadic propositional (non-temporalized) systems, approached from both the axiomatic angle and in terms of possible worlds models. A leading theme in the exposition here is the study of the possibility of translating various such systems into corresponding alethic modal systems, in the manner of Anderson and Smiley. The author's procedure is typically to establish completeness results for the deontic systems, completeness results for the alethic modal systems, and then consider the relation between the respective possible worlds semantic structures. This material indeed forms the core of the book, and the reader interested in such questions will find the exposition most valuable. The author not only gathers known results, but also supplements them with new ones, and new conjectures concerning in particular certain deontic-and-modal systems, that contain both kinds of operator. The focus on questions of completeness and translatability, applied not just to one or two sample questions but to basketsful of variant ones, does not leave the author much space to discuss certain problems of a more foundational nature, and certain special topics related to the application of the logic of norms to legal reasoning. Of the former kind is the question of whether norms may bear truth-values, and the import of the answer on the shape of a logic of norms; also the possibility of reconstructing deontic logic using Castañeda's proposed distinction between propositions and practitions. Of the latter kind is the Kanger- Lindahl classification and analysis of rights relations following the pre-formal ideas of Hohfeld. A condensed version of the book (minus the appendix) has also been published under the title ``Deontic logic'' in Handbook of philosophical logic, Volume II: Extensions of classical logic, Synthese Library 165, 605-714 (1984; Zbl 0572.03003).
      0 references

      Identifiers

      0 references
      0 references
      0 references
      0 references