Thermodynamic susceptibility as a measure of cooperative behavior in social dilemmas

DOI10.1063/5.0015655zbMATH Open1454.91013arXiv1910.03949OpenAlexW2980097285WikidataQ100412109 ScholiaQ100412109MaRDI QIDQ5139751FDOQ5139751

Authors: Colin Benjamin, Aditya Prasad Dash 

Publication date: 10 December 2020

Published in: Chaos: An Interdisciplinary Journal of Nonlinear Science (Search for Journal in Brave)

Abstract: The emergence of cooperation in the thermodynamic limit of social dilemmas is an emerging field of research. While numerical approaches (using replicator dynamics) are dime a dozen, analytical approaches are rare. A particularly useful analytical approach is to utilize a mapping between the spin-1/2 Ising model in 1-D and the social dilemma game and calculate the magnetization, which is the net difference between the fraction of cooperators and defectors in a social dilemma. In this paper, we look at the susceptibility, which probes the net change in the fraction of players adopting a certain strategy, for both classical and quantum social dilemmas. The reason being, in statistical mechanics problems, the thermodynamic susceptibility as compared to magnetization is a more sensitive probe for microscopic behavior, e.g., observing small changes in a population adopting a certain strategy. In this paper, we find the thermodynamic susceptibility for reward, sucker's payoff and temptation in classical Prisoner's Dilemma to be positive, implying that the turnover from defect to cooperate is greater than vice-versa, although the Nash Equilibrium for the two-player game is to defect. In classical Hawk-Dove game, the thermodynamic susceptibility for resource suggests that the number of players switching to Hawk from Dove strategy is dominant. Entanglement in Quantum Prisoner's Dilemma (QPD) has a non-trivial role in determining the behavior of thermodynamic susceptibility. At maximal entanglement, we find that sucker's payoff and temptation increase the number of players switching to defect. In the zero-temperature limit, we find that there are two second-order phase transitions in the game, marked by a divergence in the susceptibility. This behavior is similar to that seen in Type-II superconductors wherein also two second-order phase transitions are seen.

Full work available at URL: https://arxiv.org/abs/1910.03949

Recommendations

• Triggers for cooperative behavior in the thermodynamic limit: a case study in public goods game
• Cooperation risk and Nash equilibrium: quantitative description for realistic players
• The emergence of cooperation in the thermodynamic limit
• Dynamical systems game theory. II: A new approach to the problem of the social dilemma
• Agent behavior and transitions in \(N\)-person social dilemma games

zbMATH Keywords

cooperationsocial dilemmasthermodynamic susceptibility

Mathematics Subject Classification ID

Cooperative games (91A12) Applications of statistical and quantum mechanics to economics (econophysics) (91B80)

Cites Work

• Quantum Games and Quantum Strategies
• Title not available (Why is that?)
• The emergence of cooperation in the thermodynamic limit
• The Ehrenfest classification of phase transitions: Introduction and evolution
• Triggers for cooperative behavior in the thermodynamic limit: a case study in public goods game
• Quantum Nash equilibrium in the thermodynamic limit
• Game Theory
• Entanglement renders free riding redundant in the thermodynamic limit

Cited In (4)

• Game dynamics of emotion evolution based on the Moran process
• Vaccination dilemma in the thermodynamic limit
• The emergence of cooperation in the thermodynamic limit
• Non-thermal transitions in a model inspired by moral decisions

This page was built for publication: Thermodynamic susceptibility as a measure of cooperative behavior in social dilemmas

Report a bug (only for logged in users!)Click here to report a bug for this page (MaRDI item Q5139751)