scientific article; zbMATH DE number 2233198

From MaRDI portal
Publication:5708290





In the first part, classical experiments are described as analogues to quantum paradoxes. Each has a short section: ``The two sources experiment corresponds to the quantum 2-slit, ``Is the bird in the cage or not, to Schrödinger's cat, ``Split coins and recoiling particles to the EPR experiment, and ``Bell's inequalities. The second part of the paper is a long appendix (7 out of a total 16 pages) presenting the \(\sigma\)-algebraic foundations of probabilities. The classical examples are each described and predictions developed based on random variables over appropriate measure spaces. For example the 2-source experiment concerns ``two sources emitting continuously monochromatic light of frequency, located at \(x^{\pm} = (0,0,\pm h)\) (p. 135). A randomizing ``Mr Prankster tosses one or two coins to determine which source will shine, and an observer attempts to predict the outcome. The ``bird in the cage involves a bird that is released when a light bulb expires. The bird caretaker gets a penalty if the bird escapes, and predictions are made about the caretaker's fortune. The ``split coins experiment first considers random occurrences of red or blue faces on a coin and expressions for predicting outcomes of multiple colour measurements. Next ``Mr Prankster splits the two coins, and measurements are made under various conditions on spatially separate pieces of the same coin. Lastly ``Bell's inequalities is a one page discussion deriving inequalities in the case of three random variables taking values in \([-1,1]\). At the start we are told the analogues will show that ``strangeness in quantum theory comes not from ``phenomena that are intrinsically random but from ``the inner structure of the mathematical model itself (p. 133). We are also told the ``emphasis is on examining in what does the process of prediction consist of, and what is the influence of the available information on it (sic, ibid). There is however no discussion of the quantum paradoxes, nor of the particular mathematical features each was designed to illustrate. This is rather disappointing, especially as most readers interested in the quantum paradoxes will already be familiar with the \(\sigma\)-algebraic foundation of probabilities taking up nearly half of this paper. The classical experiments are interesting. They surely offer an interesting opportunity for a careful comparison of classical and quantum predictions.











This page was built for publication:

Report a bug (only for logged in users!)Click here to report a bug for this page (MaRDI item Q5708290)