scientific article; zbMATH DE number 1748607
This is a very well written paper. In 1970 \textit{A. Fine} [Phys. Rev. D 2, 1783-1787 (1970)] stated an obstruction for ideal measurements of first kind by means of interaction of a quantum object with an apparatus the proof of which was completed later by \textit{A. Shimony} [Phys. Rev. D 9, 2321-2323 (1974)]. This obstruction is sharpened in the present paper in that the author derives from the assumption \([U(|u\rangle\langle u|\otimes W)U^+, {\mathbf 1} \otimes A] = 0\) for any \(u\) in a linear subspace of \({\mathcal H}_1\), an arbitrary but fixed density operator \(W\) on \({\mathcal H}_2\), and an arbitrary but fixed unitarian \(U\) on \({\mathcal H}_1 \otimes {\mathcal H}_2\), which means that the pointer observable \(A\) on \({\mathcal H}_2\) has an objective value after the measurement process, that (in consequence) the expectation value of \(A\) is independent of the initial state \(u\) of the object. This conclusion would be indeed a hard and demoralizing obstruction when the assumption would be realistic. But, fortunately, it is not: Since \(U\) is assumed to be unitary the optimal result of the process can be for certain \(\psi_{j0} \in {\mathcal H}_2 \) , \(|\psi_{j0}\rangle\langle \psi_{j0}|\) being an eigenprojection of the initial \(W\) of the apparatus, the entangled pure state \[ \Phi_j(u) = U(u \otimes \psi_{j0}) = \sum_{\nu = 0}^{\infty} \langle \varphi_{\nu}|u\rangle \varphi_{\nu} \otimes \psi_{j\nu}, \] \(\varphi_{\nu}\) and \(\psi_{j\mu}\) being orthonormal systems in \({\mathcal H}_1\) and \({\mathcal H}_2\), respectively. Clearly, \(|\Phi_j(u)\rangle\langle \Phi_j(u)|\) do not commute with \({\mathbf 1} \otimes A\), where the pointer observabnle is assumed to be \[ A = \sum_{k,\mu} f(\mu)|\psi_{k\mu}\rangle\langle \psi_{k\mu}|,\quad f:{\mathbf N}_0 \rightarrow {\mathbb R}, \] with the function \(f\) being injective and \(|f|\leq C < \infty\). But \({\mathbf 1} \otimes A\) commutes with the density operators \[ \sum_{\nu = 0}^{\infty} |\langle \varphi_{\nu}|u\rangle|^2|\varphi_{\nu} \otimes\psi_{j\nu}\rangle\langle \varphi_{\nu} \otimes\psi_{j\nu}|, \] the latter being the results of a decoherence of the \(\Phi_j(u)\). The use of the statistical operator \(W\) for the apparatus is just to take into account that it has to be a many body system allowing for this decoherence by irreversible (non-unitary) dynamics. Otherwise the values of \(A\) cannot become objective ones. This knowledge is very old and the obstruction considered by the present author just demonstrates how essential it is. For the entire collection see [Zbl 0948.00058].
- The quantum measurement problem enhanced
- On the applicability of the quantum measurement formalism
- Quantum theory and the limits of objectivity
- Quantum measurement process with an ideal detector array
- Extensive measurement with incomparability
- A sub-ensemble theory of ideal quantum measurement processes
- Quantum theory of measurement and the polar decomposition of an interaction
- Contextual background
- An impossibility theorem for parameter independent hidden variable theories
- Subsystem measurement in unitary quantum measurement theory with redundant entanglement
- ``Evaluations of observables versus measurements in quantum theory
- Insolubility of the quantum measurement problem
- Unitary measurements of discrete quantities in quantum mechanics
- UnfinishedWork: A Bequest
- Momentum conservation forbids sharp localisation
- Robustness in quantum measurements
- scientific article; zbMATH DE number 1971748 (Why is no real title available?)
- scientific article; zbMATH DE number 1748595 (Why is no real title available?)
- scientific article; zbMATH DE number 2103530 (Why is no real title available?)
- Insolubility of the quantum measurement problem for unsharp observables
- Objectivity in quantum measurement
- Faithful pointer for qubit measurement
This page was built for publication:
Report a bug (only for logged in users!)Click here to report a bug for this page (MaRDI item Q4530493)