Murphy's law in algebraic geometry: Badly-behaved deformation spaces

DOI10.1007/S00222-005-0481-9zbMATH Open1095.14006arXivmath/0411469OpenAlexW1994327923MaRDI QIDQ2494166FDOQ2494166

Authors: R. Vakil 

Publication date: 16 June 2006

Published in: Inventiones Mathematicae (Search for Journal in Brave)

Abstract: We consider the question: ``How bad can the deformation space of an object be? The answer seems to be: ``Unless there is some a priori reason otherwise, the deformation space may be as bad as possible. We show this for a number of important moduli spaces. More precisely, every singularity of finite type over Z (up to smooth parameters) appears on: the Hilbert scheme of curves in projective space; and the moduli spaces of smooth projective general-type surfaces (or higher-dimensional varieties), plane curves with nodes and cusps, stable sheaves, isolated threefold singularities, and more. The objects themselves are not pathological, and are in fact as nice as can be: the curves are smooth, the surfaces have very ample canonical bundle, the stable sheaves are torsion-free of rank 1, the singularities are normal and Cohen-Macaulay, etc. This justifies Mumford's philosophy that even moduli spaces of well-behaved objects should be arbitrarily bad unless there is an a priori reason otherwise. Thus one can construct a smooth curve in projective space whose deformation space has any given number of components, each with any given singularity type, with any given non-reduced behavior along various associated subschemes. Similarly one can give a surface over F_p that lifts to Z/p^7 but not Z/p^8. (Of course the results hold in the holomorphic category as well.) It is usually difficult to compute deformation spaces directly from obstruction theories. We circumvent this by relating them to more tractable deformation spaces via smooth morphisms. The essential starting point is Mnev's Universality Theorem.

Full work available at URL: https://arxiv.org/abs/math/0411469

Recommendations

• Pathologies on the Hilbert scheme of points
• Murphy's law for Hilbert function strata in the Hilbert scheme of points
• Modular deformations and space curve singularities
• Moduli and deformations
• scientific article; zbMATH DE number 194311

zbMATH Keywords

moduli spacedeformationMurphy's law

Mathematics Subject Classification ID

Singularities in algebraic geometry (14B05) Parametrization (Chow and Hilbert schemes) (14C05) Plane and space curves (14H50) Families, moduli, classification: algebraic theory (14J10) Fine and coarse moduli spaces (14D22) Deformations of singularities (14B07) Local deformation theory, Artin approximation, etc. (14B12)

Cites Work

• Title not available (Why is that?)
• Title not available (Why is that?)
• Title not available (Why is that?)
• Title not available (Why is that?)
• Notes on stable maps and quantum cohomology
• On graded rings. I
• Quotient spaces modulo algebraic groups
• Moduli of representations of the fundamental group of a smooth projective variety. I
• Abelian covers of algebraic varieties.
• Title not available (Why is that?)
• Moduli of stable sheaves. I
• Versal deformations and algebraic stacks
• On the moduli of vector bundles on an algebraic surface
• Title not available (Why is that?)
• Local contributions to global deformations of surfaces
• Title not available (Why is that?)
• Le schéma de Hilbert des courbes gauches localement Cohen-Macaulay n'est (presque) jamais réduit
• Everywhere non reduced moduli spaces
• Sur le schéma de Hilbert des variétés de codimension $2$ dans $\mathbf{P}^e$ à cône de Cohen-Macaulay
• Murphy's law in algebraic geometry: Badly-behaved deformation spaces
• On the Factoriality of Local Rings of Small Embedding Codimension
• Projectivity of complete moduli
• A desingularization of the main component of the moduli space of genus-one stable maps into \(\mathbb{P}^{n}\)
• Classification of Three-Dimensional Flips
• On the moduli spaces of surfaces of general type. Appendix: Letter of E. Bombieri written to the author
• Arithmetic Macaulayfication of projective schemes
• Deformations of Plane Curves with Nodes and Cusps
• Title not available (Why is that?)
• Title not available (Why is that?)
• Equisingular deformations of normal surface singularities. I
• ON OBSTRUCTIONS TO DEFORMATIONS OF COMPLEX ANALYTIC SURFACES
• Further Pathologies in Algebraic Geometry
• On the moduli space of diffeomorphic algebraic surfaces
• Diffeomorphism of simply connected algebraic surfaces
• Moduli of abelian varieties
• On canonical surfaces of general type with K \(2=3_{\chi}-10\)
• Algebraic surfaces of general type with small \(c^2_1\). III
• D'autres composantes non réduites de Hilb\({\mathbb{P}}^ 3\). (Other non reduced components of Hilb\({\mathbb{P}}^ 3\))
• Hilbert scheme components in characteristic 2
• Title not available (Why is that?)
• On the Hilbert scheme of curves in higher-dimensional projective space
• Automorphisms and moduli spaces of varieties with ample canonical class via deformations of abelian covers
• Genre des courbes de l'espace projectif. II
• On the Existence of Complete Families of Projective Plane Curves, which are Obstructed
• ON THE NUMBER OF IRREDUCIBLE COMPONENTS OF THE HILBERT SCHEME OF SMOOTH SPACE CURVES
• Surfaces violating Bogomolov-Miyaoka-Yau in positive characteristic
• Title not available (Why is that?)

Cited In (87)

• The expected codimension of a matroid variety
• The moduli space of matroids
• Pathologies on the Hilbert scheme of points
• Configurations of noncollinear points in the projective plane
• Smooth Hilbert schemes: their classification and geometry
• Inseparable local uniformization
• The ubiquity of smooth Hilbert schemes
• Euler characteristics of moduli spaces of torsion free sheaves on toric surfaces
• On the smoothness of lexicographic points on Hilbert schemes
• Moduli of reflexive sheaves on smooth projective 3-folds
• Fixed point loci of moduli spaces of sheaves on toric varieties
• Quiver Grassmannians and Auslander varieties for wild algebras.
• Moduli of products of stable varieties
• Local structure of abelian covers
• Topological methods in moduli theory
• Incidence geometry and universality in the tropical plane
• Irreducible components of the moduli space of rank 2 sheaves of odd determinant on projective space
• A smooth compactification of the space of genus two curves in projective space: via logarithmic geometry and Gorenstein curves
• Complete intersections of quadrics and complete intersections on Segre varieties with common specializations
• The maximum genus problem for locally Cohen-Macaulay space curves
• Erratum to: ``Burniat surfaces. II: Secondary Burniat surfaces form three connected components of the moduli space
• Extremal bundles on Calabi-Yau threefolds
• Kodaira-Spencer formality of products of complex manifolds
• The Hilbert scheme of a pair of linear spaces
• A natural smooth compactification of the space of elliptic curves in projective space
• Elementary components of Hilbert schemes of points
• On rigid compact complex surfaces and manifolds
• Burniat surfaces. II: Secondary Burniat surfaces form three connected components of the moduli space
• Brill-Noether theory for curves of a fixed gonality
• A rigid, not infinitesimally rigid surface with \(K\) ample
• The singularities of the principal component of the Hilbert scheme of points
• Disconnected moduli spaces of stable bundles on surfaces
• Murphy's law in algebraic geometry: Badly-behaved deformation spaces
• Local structure of Brill-Noether strata in the moduli space of flat stable bundles
• Components and singularities of Quot schemes and varieties of commuting matrices
• On deformation spaces of toric singularities and on singularities of K-moduli of Fano varieties
• Surfaces violating Bogomolov-Miyaoka-Yau in positive characteristic
• Hopf algebras for matroids over hyperfields
• On some examples of obstructed irregular surfaces
• Mnëv-Sturmfels universality for schemes
• Realization spaces of arrangements of convex bodies
• Complex singularities and contact topology
• Obstructions to deforming space curves lying on a smooth cubic surface
• Hypersurfaces with defect
• Obstructions to deforming curves on a 3-fold. III: Deformations of curves lying on a \(K 3\) surface
• Smooth and irreducible multigraded Hilbert schemes
• Surfaces of general type with geometric genus zero: a survey
• On representation varieties of 3-manifold groups
• A boundary divisor in the moduli spaces of stable quintic surfaces
• The compactified Jacobian can be nonreduced
• Deformations of smooth complete toric varieties: obstructions and the cup product
• Mostow strong rigidity of locally symmetric spaces revisited
• Rigid but not infinitesimally rigid compact complex manifolds
• Skeletons of stable maps. II: Superabundant geometries
• Plane algebraic curves with many cusps, with an appendix by Eugenii Shustin
• Hilbert schemes with two Borel-fixed points in arbitrary characteristic
• Irreducibility and singularities of some nested Hilbert schemes
• Matroid Theory for Algebraic Geometers
• A desingularization of the main component of the moduli space of genus-one stable maps into \(\mathbb{P}^{n}\)
• Kodaira fibrations and beyond: methods for moduli theory
• Conditional probabilities via line arrangements and point configurations
• Universality theorems for inscribed polytopes and Delaunay triangulations
• Algebraic models of local period maps and Yukawa algebras
• Obstructions to deforming curves on a 3-fold, I: A generalization of Mumford’s example and an application to 𝐻𝑜𝑚 schemes
• Murphy's law for Hilbert function strata in the Hilbert scheme of points
• Moment maps and cohomology of non-reductive quotients
• Enumerating rigid sphere packings
• A Severi type theorem for surfaces in $\mathbb {P}^6$
• Geometry of canonical genus 4 curves
• KSBA compactification of the moduli space of K3 surfaces with a purely non-symplectic automorphism of order four
• On multilinear inequalities of Hölder-Brascamp-Lieb type for torsion-free discrete abelian groups
• Special Components of the Moduli of Stable Sheaves
• Is the number of subrings of index p ^e in ℤ ⁿ polynomial in p  ?
• Nash conditional independence curve
• Universality for tropical and logarithmic maps
• Subcomplexes of certain free resolutions
• The interpolation problem: when can you pass a curve of a given type through \(n\) random points in space?
• Game theory of undirected graphical models
• On the nonconnectedness of moduli spaces of arrangements: the splitting polygon structure
• Families of 0-dimensional subspaces on supercurves of dimension \(1|1\)
• Deformation and Unobstructedness of Determinantal Schemes
• The geometry of geometries: matroid theory, old and new
• The Grassmannian of 3-planes in \(\mathbb{C}^8\) is schön
• The 4-fold Pandharipande-Thomas vertex
• Initial degenerations of spinor varieties
• Bounding embedded singularities of Hilbert schemes of points on affine three space
• Some open questions about line arrangements in the projective plane

This page was built for publication: Murphy's law in algebraic geometry: Badly-behaved deformation spaces

Report a bug (only for logged in users!)Click here to report a bug for this page (MaRDI item Q2494166)